Wells Fargo & Company (WFC) vs Citigroup Inc. (C)
C screens cheaper with faster expected growth; WFC leads on margins, balance sheet and lower volatility
Citigroup (C) is cheaper on most multiples, with a forward P/E of 9.47× against 10.38× for Wells Fargo (WFC), and Qanvo's scorecard names it the leader on valuation, growth and earnings momentum. WFC leads on profitability and quality (operating margin 21.10% versus 15.15%), financial resilience (debt/equity 2.51× versus 3.90×), lower risk (beta 0.68 versus 1.31) and technical momentum. Price returns split by period: WFC is ahead over 1, 3 and 6 months, while C is ahead over 1, 3 and 5 years. Analysts' mean targets imply similar upside, 20.67% for WFC and 21.87% for C, but these are opinions drawn from few targets. Both are banks, so free cash flow, EV-based multiples and price/sales do not compare cleanly.
Business overview
Both are US-listed, S&P 500 member Financials companies in the Banks - Diversified industry, so the business-model gap is one of mix rather than sector. Wells Fargo & Company (WFC) has a market cap of $249.38B and describes diversified banking, investment, mortgage, and consumer and commercial finance in the United States and internationally. Citigroup Inc. (C) has a market cap of $200.47B and is described as a holding company providing financial products and services. WFC reports four segments: Consumer Banking and Lending, Commercial Banking, Corporate and Investment Banking, and Wealth and Investment Management. In fiscal 2025, Consumer Banking and Lending was the largest at 43.62% of revenue. C reports Services, Markets, Banking, Wealth, U.S. Personal Banking and All Other. Its largest fiscal 2025 product lines were Markets at 27.13%, Services at 26.25% and U.S. Personal Banking at 25.90%. C also shows a geographic split: North America 85.27% and EMEA 14.73%. WFC's facts give no geographic split. WFC has 194,369 employees and C has 217,000.
- WFC's market cap of $249.38B is above C's $200.47B, though both are classed as Mega.
- WFC's largest segment, Consumer Banking and Lending, is 43.62% of revenue, while C's largest, Markets, is 27.13%.
- C's revenue is more evenly spread across three product lines (27.13%, 26.25%, 25.90%) than WFC's across its segments.
- C discloses 85.27% of revenue from North America; WFC's facts have no geographic breakdown.
Valuation
C is cheaper on most multiples, and Qanvo's valuation scorecard names it the leader (100 versus 0 for WFC, relative ranks within this pair). Trailing P/E is 10.37× for C against 10.84× for WFC, and forward P/E (based on analyst estimates) is 9.47× against 10.38×. PEG is 0.75× against 1.06×, price/sales 1.14× against 1.91×, and price/book 0.96× against 1.42×. EV/EBITDA and free-cash-flow yield are not usable here: both banks show negative enterprise value, and C's free cash flow is negative at -1.72B versus 28.91B for WFC. Price/sales and enterprise-based multiples don't compare cleanly across banks. Against its own 5-year range, WFC's trailing P/E of 10.84 sits below its 12.35 median (range 8.14 to 16.38). C's 10.37 is below its 11.91 median (range 4.79 to 23.47). Versus sector peers (median 13.03×), WFC is at the 29th percentile and C at the 22nd. C's discount comes with lower profitability (ROE 9.15% versus 12.89%) and higher leverage, so the cheaper multiple may partly reflect quality and risk, though C also has the faster expected EPS growth.
- C's forward P/E of 9.47× is below WFC's 10.38×, and below the industry median of 10.69×.
- C's PEG of 0.75× is below WFC's 1.06×.
- WFC's trailing P/E of 10.84× sits at the 29th percentile of sector peers; C's 10.37× is at the 22nd.
- C's ROE of 9.15% trails WFC's 12.89%, which may explain part of its discount.
Growth
Reported growth is mixed. Over the last year, WFC's revenue grew 6.66% against 4.56% for C, but C's EPS grew 43.96% against 17.43%. Last quarter, revenue growth was 4.25% for WFC and 4.07% for C, while EPS growth was 12.65% for WFC and 53.23% for C. Over three years, C's revenue compound rate is 18.86% against 13.97% for WFC, yet WFC's EPS compound rate is 26.26% against -0.05% for C. Qanvo's growth scorecard names C the leader (75 versus 25). The history differs in shape. WFC's quarterly EPS moved from 1.60 in Q1 FY2026 to 2 in Q2 and 1.87 in Q3. C's EPS was 1.19 in Q4 FY2025, then 3.06, 3.15 and 2.85 in the next three quarters, so it has eased in the latest quarter. C's annual EPS was 10.14 in 2021, 4.04 in 2023 and 6.99 in 2025, a much less even path than WFC's rise from 3.14 in 2022 to 6.32 in 2025. Analysts' estimates favour C: next-fiscal-year EPS growth of 12.68% versus 9.78% for WFC. Consensus EPS for the current year is 11.40 for C and 7.33 for WFC, and for the following year 12.84 and 8.05.
- C's last-year EPS growth of 43.96% is well above WFC's 17.43%, but WFC's revenue growth of 6.66% is above C's 4.56%.
- WFC's three-year EPS compound rate of 26.26% contrasts with C's -0.05%.
- Analysts expect next-year EPS growth of 12.68% for C versus 9.78% for WFC (estimates).
- C's quarterly EPS fell from 3.15 to 2.85 in the latest quarter, while WFC's fell from 2 to 1.87.
Profitability, cash flow & financial health
Wells Fargo leads the profitability and quality scorecard (100 versus 0 for Citigroup, a relative rank within this pair). Its operating margin is 21.10% against 15.15%, its net margin is 17.64% against 10.98%, and its return on equity is 12.89% against 9.15%. Operating margin moved up at both banks over the past year: 1.43% at Wells Fargo and 3.38% at Citigroup, so Citigroup is narrowing the gap from a lower base. Both are in the bottom half of large US financials on return on equity, at percentile 41 for Wells Fargo and 14 for Citigroup. Both are banks, so gross margin, free cash flow and net debt/EBITDA don't compare well with industrial companies. Reported free cash flow is also unreliable here: Wells Fargo shows $28.91B over the trailing twelve months, while Citigroup shows -1.72B. Leverage favors Wells Fargo: debt/equity is 2.51× against 3.90×, and interest coverage is 0.64× against 0.32×. Both have a Piotroski F-score of 7. The resilience scorecard puts Wells Fargo first (100 versus 0). On growth turning into economics, Citigroup's trailing EPS growth of 43.96% is faster than Wells Fargo's 17.43%, but its margins remain lower.
- Wells Fargo's operating margin is 21.10% versus 15.15% for Citigroup.
- Return on equity is 12.89% at Wells Fargo versus 9.15% at Citigroup.
- Debt/equity is 2.51× at Wells Fargo versus 3.90× at Citigroup.
- Operating margin improved 3.38% at Citigroup over the past year versus 1.43% at Wells Fargo.
Shareholder returns & capital allocation
Wells Fargo has the higher dividend yield, 2.30% versus 2.12% at Citigroup, on a payout ratio of 26.61% versus 24.78%. Both payouts are modest. Citigroup pays more per share, $2.54 over the trailing twelve months against $1.90, but its share price is higher. Wells Fargo has grown its dividend faster, 15.62% over three years across 4 years of growth, against 4.38% across 3 years at Citigroup. The latest quarterly dividend is $0.50 at Wells Fargo, up from $0.45, and $0.67 at Citigroup, up from $0.60. Both are shrinking their share counts. Citigroup's shares changed by -8.38% over the past year versus -5.16% at Wells Fargo, so Citigroup has been the heavier net repurchaser. In fiscal 2025, buybacks were $17.52B at Wells Fargo and $18.25B at Citigroup, while dividends paid were $5.43B and $5.37B. Wells Fargo's buybacks were $22.29B in fiscal 2024, against $7.52B at Citigroup, so Citigroup's repurchases have stepped up recently. Because both are banks, free cash flow isn't a clean measure of capacity to fund payouts. The data does not include stated capital targets or regulatory capital ratios.
- Dividend yield is 2.30% at Wells Fargo versus 2.12% at Citigroup.
- Three-year dividend growth is 15.62% at Wells Fargo versus 4.38% at Citigroup.
- Share count fell 8.38% at Citigroup versus 5.16% at Wells Fargo over the past year.
- Fiscal 2025 buybacks were $18.25B at Citigroup versus $17.52B at Wells Fargo.
Earnings intelligence
Over the last four reported quarters, Citigroup's EPS surprises were: Oct 13, 2026 +7.14% (2.85 vs 2.66 consensus), Jul 14, 2026 +14.96%, Apr 14, 2026 +15.47% and Jan 21, 2026 -33.89%. Wells Fargo's were +1.08% (1.87 vs 1.85), +13.95%, -1.27% and -2.41%. Citigroup has a three-quarter beat streak against two for Wells Fargo. Revenue surprises were also better at Citigroup in the latest quarter (0.46% vs -1.94% for Wells Fargo). Stock reactions to the latest report were both negative: Citigroup -7.30% and Wells Fargo -2.90%, despite EPS beats at both. Citigroup's other reactions over the four reports ranged from -4.14% to 4.28%; Wells Fargo's from -7.33% to -0.18%. Analysts' 30-day EPS revisions are 0.70% for Citigroup and 0.01% for Wells Fargo, both small, and Qanvo's earnings momentum scorecard puts Citigroup ahead (100 vs 0, relative ranks). Both companies' next report is on Jan 14, 2027, 58 days away, and neither date is confirmed. No company guidance appears in the facts. The latest report strengthened Citigroup's relative earnings case on surprise size and streak, though its share price fell more.
- Latest EPS surprise: Citigroup 7.14% versus Wells Fargo 1.08%.
- Latest revenue surprise: Citigroup 0.46% versus Wells Fargo -1.94%.
- Post-earnings move on Oct 13, 2026: Citigroup -7.30% versus Wells Fargo -2.90%.
- Estimated next report date is Jan 14, 2027 for both, unconfirmed.
Technicals, relative performance & risk
Price returns are mixed by period. Wells Fargo leads over 1 month (1.1% vs -1.4%), 3 months (-5.5% vs -13.4%) and 6 months (11.2% vs -2.0%). Citigroup leads over 1 year (22.2% vs -0.9%), 3 years (165.0% vs 93.2%) and 5 years (79.4% vs 65.9%). Total returns with dividends keep the same order, for example 1 year at 24.0% for Citigroup versus 0.8% for Wells Fargo. Qanvo's momentum scorecard favours Wells Fargo (60 vs 40), and its relative strength rating is 61 versus Citigroup's 70. Both trade below their 200-day averages: Wells Fargo by 0.84% and Citigroup by 5.55%, with Citigroup also 5.70% below its 50-day average. The 14-day RSI is 43.74 for Wells Fargo and 40.99 for Citigroup. Wells Fargo is 15.42% below its 52-week high, Citigroup 18.94% below. On risk, Wells Fargo is calmer: beta 0.68 vs 1.31, 30-day historical volatility 25.94% vs 30.56%, and a 1-year maximum drawdown of -23.83% against -18.69% for Citigroup, which is the one measure where Citigroup is shallower. Citigroup's stronger fundamentals scorecard on growth and valuation sits against weaker recent price action.
- 6-month price return: Wells Fargo 11.2% versus Citigroup -2.0%; 1-year reverses to Citigroup 22.2% versus -0.9%.
- Distance from the 200-day average: Wells Fargo -0.84% versus Citigroup -5.55%.
- Beta: Wells Fargo 0.68 versus Citigroup 1.31.
- 1-year maximum drawdown: Wells Fargo -23.83% versus Citigroup -18.69%.
Analyst & ownership sentiment
Analysts' opinions lean positive on both, though they are opinions, not facts about the future. The consensus label is Buy for each. WFC's breakdown is 28 Buy, 28 Hold and 4 Sell, while C's is 17 Buy, 9 Hold and 1 Sell, so C has a larger share of Buy ratings. The mean price target is 99.78 for WFC, implying 20.67% upside, and 146.17 for C, implying 21.87%. Both are based on small samples (9 targets for WFC, 6 for C). Recent target changes were mostly trims: RBC Capital cut its WFC target from 100 to 92, and Evercore ISI cut its C target from 140 to 135. Analysts' 30-day EPS revisions were 0.70% for C and 0.01% for WFC, with no upgrades or downgrades for either in 30 days. Institutional ownership is almost identical at 77.33% for WFC and 77.71% for C. Three-month changes were 4.50% and 4.67%, though these filings lag by weeks. No insider buying or selling was recorded in the last 90 days for either; the listed insider entries are awards and gifts. Short interest is 1.06% of float for WFC and 1.32% for C. WFC's short interest rose 19.91% in the latest period, while C's was roughly flat at -0.11%.
- Mean analyst targets imply 20.67% upside for WFC and 21.87% for C, which are opinions based on 9 and 6 targets.
- C has 17 Buy ratings against 1 Sell; WFC has 28 Buy against 4 Sell and 28 Hold.
- Short interest is 1.06% of float for WFC versus 1.32% for C, but WFC's rose 19.91% in the latest period.
- Institutional ownership is 77.33% for WFC and 77.71% for C, with no insider open-market trades at either.
Risks & catalysts
Valuation is not stretched at either bank, but both rely on estimates: forward P/E of 10.38× for WFC and 9.47× for C depend on analysts' EPS forecasts. C's lower multiples come with weaker profitability, with an operating margin of 15.15% against 21.10% for WFC and ROE of 9.15% against 12.89%. Leverage ratios are high for both and not directly comparable with non-financial companies. Debt to equity is 3.90× for C and 2.51× for WFC, and Qanvo's resilience scorecard favors WFC. Volatility differs. C's one-year beta is 1.31 against 0.68 for WFC, and its 30-day historical volatility is 30.56% against 25.94%. C is 18.94% below its 52-week high and WFC is 15.42% below. C's one-year free cash flow is negative at -1.72B, while WFC's is 28.91B, though cash flow is hard to interpret for banks. C's recent earnings reaction was -7.30%, and WFC's was -2.90%. Catalysts: both are expected to report on Jan 14, 2027 (58 days away, not yet confirmed). Consensus EPS for that quarter is 1.84 for WFC and 2.34 for C. The most recent ex-dividend dates were Nov 6, 2026 for WFC (0.5 per share) and Nov 2, 2026 for C (0.67).
- C's beta of 1.31 is nearly double WFC's 0.68, so C has the larger market-swing risk.
- Debt to equity is 3.90× for C and 2.51× for WFC.
- C's operating margin of 15.15% trails WFC's 21.10%.
- Both are due to report on Jan 14, 2027, not yet confirmed, with consensus EPS of 1.84 for WFC and 2.34 for C.
Analysis written November 18, 2026. AI-generated, for information only; not investment advice.