Compare stocks

Visa Inc. (V) vs Mastercard Incorporated (MA)

Visa and Mastercard: near-identical multiples, with Mastercard growing faster and Visa ahead on margins

Visa and Mastercard are very similar payments networks on valuation and risk, and Qanvo's scorecard finds no clear leader on valuation (50 each), resilience or lower risk. Mastercard leads on growth (revenue growth 15.30% versus 14.76%, 3-year EPS growth 17.32% versus 13.85%) and earnings momentum (28-quarter beat streak versus 9). Visa leads on profitability and quality (operating margin 61.24% versus 58.76%) and technical momentum (1-year price return 27.9% versus 20.3%). Forward P/E is 27.20× for Visa and 28.28× for Mastercard (analyst estimates), and both sit far above the sector median of 11.19×. Mastercard's leverage looks heavier (debt to equity 3.54× versus 0.61×), though its equity base is small.

Business overview

Both companies are US-listed Financials names in the Financial - Credit Services industry, and both describe themselves as payments technology firms. Per their profiles, each handles authorization, clearing and settlement of transactions for consumers, merchants, financial institutions, businesses and governments. Visa's profile highlights its VisaNet processing network; Mastercard's mentions credit deferral, prepaid and commercial payment products plus value-added solutions. The business models look broadly similar, so most ratios compare directly. By size, Visa is larger with a market cap of $716.43B against $565.01B for Mastercard; both are in the Mega tier. Visa reports 34,800 employees and Mastercard 39,800. Geographically, Visa's fiscal 2026 revenue is 62.04% non-US and 37.96% US. Mastercard's fiscal 2025 revenue is 57.17% International Markets and 42.83% Americas. These splits use different category definitions and fiscal years, so they are not exact like-for-like. Mastercard splits revenue 59.39% Payment Network and 40.61% Value-Added Services And Solutions, while Visa's product lines are broken out differently (data processing, service and international transaction revenues, less client incentives).

  • Visa's market cap of $716.43B is above Mastercard's $565.01B.
  • Visa earns 62.04% of revenue outside the US versus 57.17% international for Mastercard, on differing definitions.
  • Mastercard's Value-Added Services And Solutions is 40.61% of revenue; Visa does not report the same split.
  • Both sit in Financial - Credit Services, so there is no sector mismatch to flag.

Valuation

On earnings multiples the two are close, with Visa slightly cheaper. Visa trades at a trailing P/E of 30.48× and a forward P/E of 27.20× (based on analyst estimates), versus 33.32× and 28.28× for Mastercard. Price/sales is nearly identical at 15.61× for Visa and 15.57× for Mastercard. PEG is 1.94× for Visa and 1.81× for Mastercard, so Mastercard is lower on that measure. Qanvo's valuation scorecard finds no clear leader (50 each). EV/EBITDA and free-cash-flow yield are not given as multiples in the facts, so they cannot be compared directly. Against their own 5-year ranges, Visa's 30.48× sits below its median of 31.43× (range 26.2× to 42.78×). Mastercard's 33.32× is further below its median of 36.99× (range 28.59× to 47.53×). Against Financials peers, both rank high: Visa's trailing P/E is in the 94th percentile (sector median 13.03×) and Mastercard's in the 96th. A premium to the sector reflects higher margins and growth rather than a clear mispricing. Mastercard's slightly higher multiple coincides with faster growth in the data, while Visa leads on profitability.

  • Visa's forward P/E of 27.20× is below Mastercard's 28.28× (analyst estimates).
  • Mastercard's PEG of 1.81× is lower than Visa's 1.94×.
  • Visa is 0.95 turns below its 5-year median P/E of 31.43×, while Mastercard is below its median of 36.99× by a wider margin.
  • Both trade far above the sector median trailing P/E of 13.03×.

Growth

Reported growth favors Mastercard slightly, and Qanvo's growth scorecard names it the leader (100 versus 0 for Visa, a relative rank). Revenue growth over the last year is 15.30% for Mastercard against 14.76% for Visa; last quarter was 14.01% against 13.19%. Over three years, revenue compounds at 13.82% for Mastercard and 12.02% for Visa. EPS growth is 22.25% against 20.76% for the year and 17.32% against 13.85% on a 3-year basis. The annual history shows steady expansion for both. Visa's revenue rose from $24.11B in fiscal 2021 to $45.90B in fiscal 2026, and its quarterly revenue climbed from $10.72B to $12.14B over the last four reported quarters. Mastercard's revenue went from $18.88B in fiscal 2021 to $32.79B in fiscal 2025, with quarterly revenue from $8.60B to $9.81B. Neither shows accelerating revenue quarters in the data. Fiscal years end in different months, so labels cover different periods. Analyst estimates, not reported results, point to next-year EPS growth of 15.66% for Mastercard versus 14.00% for Visa. Consensus EPS for the current fiscal year is $20.07 for Mastercard and $15.04 for Visa.

  • Mastercard's trailing revenue growth of 15.30% is above Visa's 14.76%.
  • Mastercard's 3-year EPS compound growth of 17.32% is above Visa's 13.85%.
  • Analysts expect next-year EPS growth of 15.66% for Mastercard versus 14.00% for Visa (estimates).
  • Neither company shows revenue acceleration; both have 0 accelerating quarters.

Profitability, cash flow & financial health

Qanvo's profitability and quality scorecard favours Visa (score 67) over Mastercard (33), a relative rank within this pair. Visa's operating margin is 61.24% against 58.76%, and its net margin is 51.20% against 46.73%. Visa's operating margin rose 1.25% over the past year, while Mastercard's changed by -0.39%, so Visa's economics are improving more while both grow revenue at similar rates (14.76% for Visa, 15.30% for Mastercard). Return on equity is 63.51% for Visa and 231.40% for Mastercard. Mastercard's figure is inflated by a small equity base of $6.75B, so it is not a clean sign of better quality. Free cash flow over the trailing twelve months is $22.06B for Visa on $45.90B of revenue, and $15.43B for Mastercard on $36.29B. Both companies convert a large share of revenue to cash, and gross profit is not comparable because Mastercard reports it equal to revenue. On leverage, Visa's debt to equity is 0.61× against 3.54× for Mastercard, and net debt is $7.99B against $13.47B. Interest coverage is similar at 24.53× for Visa and 26.26× for Mastercard. The Piotroski score is 7 for Visa and 5 for Mastercard. Qanvo's resilience category shows no clear leader, because the mixed measures offset each other.

  • Visa's operating margin of 61.24% is above Mastercard's 58.76%, and it improved by 1.25% against -0.39% for Mastercard.
  • Visa's debt to equity of 0.61× is well below Mastercard's 3.54×, though Mastercard's interest coverage of 26.26× is slightly above Visa's 24.53×.
  • Mastercard's ROE of 231.40% exceeds Visa's 63.51%, but it rests on equity of only $6.75B.
  • Visa's trailing free cash flow of $22.06B is above Mastercard's $15.43B, on a larger revenue base.

Shareholder returns & capital allocation

Neither company is an income stock. Visa yields 0.67% and Mastercard 0.54%, both low against a sector median of 1.88%. Payout ratios are modest, at 22.63% for Visa and 18.20% for Mastercard, which leaves most earnings for buybacks and reinvestment. Mastercard pays more per share ($3.48 over the trailing twelve months against $2.79 for Visa) because its share price is higher. Dividend growth is almost identical: 15.71% a year over three years for Visa and 15.75% for Mastercard. Visa has raised its dividend for 17 years, Mastercard for 14. Visa's latest quarterly payment is $0.78 against $0.67 before it, while Mastercard's is $0.87. Buybacks dominate capital returns. Visa repurchased $20.45B of stock in fiscal 2026 and paid $5.11B in dividends. Mastercard's latest full fiscal year (2025) shows $11.73B of buybacks and $2.76B of dividends. The share count fell 3.24% at Visa and 3.20% at Mastercard over the past year, so dilution is a non-issue for both. The fiscal years end in different months, so these totals cover different periods.

  • Visa's dividend yield of 0.67% is above Mastercard's 0.54%, and its payout ratio of 22.63% is higher than Mastercard's 18.20%.
  • Three-year dividend growth is 15.71% for Visa and 15.75% for Mastercard, effectively tied.
  • Visa's share count fell 3.24% against 3.20% for Mastercard, a near-identical pace of buybacks.
  • Visa's fiscal 2026 buybacks of $20.45B exceed Mastercard's fiscal 2025 buybacks of $11.73B, but the periods differ.

Earnings intelligence

Both companies beat EPS consensus in each of the last four reported quarters, but Mastercard's surprises were larger. Mastercard reported EPS of 5.31 versus 5.17 (2.71% surprise, revenue 1.50%) on Oct 29, 2026, after 5.04 versus 4.77 (5.66%), 4.60 versus 4.41 (4.31%) and 4.76 versus 4.24 (12.26%). Visa reported 3.48 versus 3.44 (1.16%, revenue 0.40%) on Oct 27, 2026, after 3.32 versus 3.23 (2.79%), 3.31 versus 3.10 (6.77%) and 3.17 versus 3.14 (0.96%). Mastercard's beat streak is 28 quarters versus 9 for Visa. Stock reactions differ. Mastercard moved 4.54% after its latest report, then 1.74%, -5.67% and 3.34% in prior quarters. Visa moved -0.88%, 1.71%, 8.14% and -1.58%. Visa's largest recent reaction was positive; Mastercard's was a decline despite a beat. Estimate revisions are small for both: 30-day EPS consensus revisions are 0.53% for Mastercard and 0.01% for Visa. Both next report on Jan 28, 2027, not confirmed (estimated). Next-quarter EPS consensus is 5.11 for Mastercard and 3.64 for Visa. No company guidance appears in the facts. The latest report favors Mastercard's relative case, consistent with Qanvo's earnings momentum lead.

  • Mastercard's latest EPS surprise was 2.71% versus 1.16% for Visa.
  • Mastercard has beaten EPS estimates 28 quarters in a row versus 9 for Visa.
  • Over 30 days, EPS estimates were revised up 0.53% for Mastercard versus 0.01% for Visa.
  • Next earnings for both are estimated for Jan 28, 2027, 72 days away and unconfirmed.

Technicals, relative performance & risk

Relative price returns are split. Mastercard led over 1 month (4.8% versus 3.4%) and 6 months (27.7% versus 25.3%). Visa led over 3 months (16.1% versus 14.8%), 1 year (27.9% versus 20.3%), 3 years (66.7% versus 59.7%) and 5 years (103.2% versus 79.8%). Total returns with dividends keep the same order, such as 1 year at 28.7% for Visa versus 20.9% for Mastercard. Both trade above their averages. Price versus the 200-day average is 19.76% for Visa and 18.89% for Mastercard; versus the 50-day, 6.22% and 7.05%. Versus the 20-day, Visa is -0.16% and Mastercard 0.35%. RSI is 54.42 for Visa and 55.4 for Mastercard, neutral for both. Both sit about 5% below 52-week highs (-5.76% Visa, -5.32% Mastercard). Relative strength ratings are 92 and 91. Risk is similar: 1-year beta 0.33 versus 0.3, 30-day volatility 24.81% versus 26.20%, and 1-year maximum drawdown -17.35% versus -18.75%. Qanvo gives Visa the momentum lead but sees no clear lower-risk leader. Strong momentum sits alongside high valuations for both, with forward P/Es of 27.20 and 28.28 against a sector median of 11.19.

  • Visa's 1-year price return of 27.9% compares with 18.32% shown for Mastercard in the snapshot and 20.3% in the ranking, so Visa leads either way.
  • Visa's relative strength rating is 92 versus 91 for Mastercard.
  • Visa's 1-year maximum drawdown of -17.35% is shallower than Mastercard's -18.75%.
  • Mastercard's 30-day volatility is 26.20% versus 24.81% for Visa.

Analyst & ownership sentiment

Analysts' opinions are similar for both. Visa carries a "Strong Buy" rating label from 25 analysts, with a mean target price of 450.53, which is 8.10% above the current price of 416.77. Mastercard also has a "Strong Buy" label from 25 analysts, with a mean target of 707.90, or 9.63% above its price of 645.73. The detailed tallies differ: Visa shows 53 Buy and 9 Hold, while Mastercard shows 1 Strong Buy, 50 Buy and 14 Hold. Neither has any Sell ratings. These are opinions, not predictions. Over the last 30 days, estimate revisions were small: Visa's EPS estimate moved 0.01% against 0.53% for Mastercard, and neither had upgrades or downgrades. Institutions hold 87.37% of Mastercard against 78.90% of Visa. Their holdings rose 2.22% at Visa and 1.69% at Mastercard over three months, though 13F filings lag by weeks. Insiders were net sellers at both, with no buys in 90 days: 14 sales totalling -48.9M at Visa, against 9 sales totalling -11.7M at Mastercard. Short interest is low at both: 1.24% of float for Visa and 0.81% for Mastercard.

  • Mean targets imply 8.10% upside for Visa against 9.63% for Mastercard, both analyst opinions.
  • Insider net selling over 90 days was -48.9M at Visa versus -11.7M at Mastercard.
  • Short interest is 1.24% of float at Visa versus 0.81% at Mastercard.
  • Institutional ownership is 78.90% at Visa versus 87.37% at Mastercard.

Risks & catalysts

Valuation is the shared risk. Forward P/E is 27.20× for Visa and 28.28× for Mastercard, against a sector median of 11.19×, so both prices depend on analysts' growth estimates being met. Those estimates carry next-year EPS growth of 14.00% for Visa and 15.66% for Mastercard. Both are within about 6% of their all-time highs (-5.76% and -5.32%), and each fell more than 2% on the latest day. Balance sheet structure differs. Mastercard's debt-to-equity is 3.54× against 0.61× for Visa, because its equity is only 6.75B, which makes the ratio and its 231.40% return on equity hard to compare. Interest coverage is similar at 24.53× for Visa and 26.26× for Mastercard. Volatility is comparable: 30-day historical volatility is 24.81% for Visa and 26.20% for Mastercard, and the one-year maximum drawdown is -17.35% against -18.75%. A news headline mentions a hearing involving both companies on premium card pilots, but no details are in the facts. Catalysts: both are expected to report on Jan 28, 2027 (not confirmed). Visa's last quarterly dividend had an ex-date of Nov 10, 2026, and Mastercard's was Oct 9, 2026.

  • Forward P/E is 27.20× for Visa and 28.28× for Mastercard versus a sector median of 11.19×.
  • Debt-to-equity is 3.54× at Mastercard versus 0.61× at Visa.
  • Maximum one-year drawdown was -18.75% for Mastercard versus -17.35% for Visa.
  • Both next report on Jan 28, 2027, 72 days away, with the date unconfirmed.

Analysis written November 18, 2026. AI-generated, for information only; not investment advice.