PayPal Holdings, Inc. (PYPL) vs Block, Inc. (XYZ)
PayPal is cheaper with higher margins; Block grows faster, has net cash and stronger one-year momentum
PayPal screens cheaper (forward P/E 9.86× vs 15.10×; trailing P/E 10.44× vs 103.67×) and leads Qanvo's valuation, profitability and earnings-momentum categories. Block leads growth (75 vs 25), technical momentum (60 vs 40) and financial resilience (100 vs 0), with revenue growth of 6.98% vs 4.36% and net cash against PayPal's net debt. Risk is mixed with no clear leader: Block's beta is 1.77 vs 0.9 and its 30-day volatility is 56.47% vs 24.43%, while PayPal's one-year drawdown was deeper (-37.87% vs -31.31%). Analysts lean the other way from the valuation: Hold for PayPal (mean target 56.45, below the price) and Buy for Block (mean target 95.11). The companies sit in different sectors (Financials vs Technology), so margins and leverage compare less directly.
Business overview
Both are large US-listed payments companies, but they sit in different sectors. PayPal (NASDAQ) is classed as Financials, Financial - Credit Services, with a market cap of $49.34B. Block (NYSE) is classed as Technology, Software - Infrastructure, with a market cap of $47.81B. PayPal is slightly larger, by about $1.5B. Per the profile descriptions, PayPal runs a global platform for digital transactions for businesses and consumers, with brands including PayPal, Venmo and Braintree, and reach across roughly 200 markets. Block builds tools for merchants to take card payments, with reporting and analytics, next-day settlement and hardware such as card readers and the Square Stand. PayPal's description points to a consumer and merchant network; Block's to merchant point-of-sale tools. Geography differs sharply: the United States was 56.88% of PayPal's fiscal 2025 revenue versus 91.70% for Block. PayPal's revenue is mostly transaction revenue (89.83%). Block's product segment data is incomplete in the facts, so a like-for-like product split is not possible. Sector differences mean margins and leverage compare less directly.
- PayPal's market cap of $49.34B is just above Block's $47.81B.
- US revenue was 56.88% of PayPal's total versus 91.70% for Block, so Block is far more US-concentrated.
- PayPal has 23,800 employees versus 10,205 at Block.
Valuation
PayPal screens cheaper on most measures. Its trailing P/E is 10.44× against 103.67× for Block, and its forward P/E (based on analysts' estimates) is 9.86× against 15.10×. Price/sales is 1.44× for PayPal and 1.86× for Block. Block's PEG is 0.50× versus 1.62× for PayPal, reflecting its higher expected EPS growth. Block's EV/EBITDA is 35.89× and its free-cash-flow yield is 7.22%; neither is available for PayPal in the facts. Qanvo's valuation scorecard favours PayPal (75 vs 25). Against its own 5-year range, PayPal's trailing P/E of 10.44× is near the low end (low 8.1×, median 17.5×, high 56.45×). Block's 103.67× is above its median of 59.16×, though its range is wide (11.97× to 704.83×) because earnings have been depressed. Against sector peers, PayPal's trailing P/E sits at the 29th percentile (sector median 12.56×); Block's is at the 88th percentile (median 28.26×), while its forward P/E is at the 36th percentile. PayPal's lower multiples coincide with slower growth and a lower analyst rating. Block's high trailing P/E reflects thin net income of $461.1M, so forward and PEG measures are more informative.
- Trailing P/E is 10.44× for PayPal versus 103.67× for Block.
- Forward P/E is 9.86× for PayPal versus 15.10× for Block, both analyst-estimate based.
- PEG is 0.50× for Block versus 1.62× for PayPal, the one measure favouring Block.
- Block's free-cash-flow yield is 7.22%; no comparable figure is given for PayPal.
Growth
Block leads on Qanvo's growth scorecard (75 vs 25). Reported revenue growth over the last year is 6.98% for Block versus 4.36% for PayPal, and in the latest quarter 9.88% versus 1.98%. Three-year revenue CAGR is 11.33% for Block against 6.43% for PayPal. Block's revenue has risen over six accelerating quarters, while PayPal shows no acceleration streak. EPS tells a more mixed story. PayPal's EPS grew 5.01% over the year and -3.85% in the latest quarter, with a 3-year CAGR of 37.30%. Block's EPS fell 85.05% over the year, though it rose 24.32% in the latest quarter. History shows why: Block's annual diluted EPS went from 4.55 in fiscal 2024 to 2.1 in fiscal 2025, while PayPal's moved from 3.99 to 5.41. Quarterly revenue has been steadier for PayPal (about $8.3B to $8.7B), while Block's rose from $6.06B to $6.72B over the last three quarters. Analysts' estimates: next-year EPS growth is 30.23% for Block versus 6.08% for PayPal. Consensus EPS for the current fiscal year is 5.59 for PayPal and 4.15 for Block; for the following year it is 5.93 and 5.41. These are opinions, not results.
- Latest-quarter revenue growth is 9.88% for Block versus 1.98% for PayPal.
- Three-year revenue CAGR is 11.33% for Block versus 6.43% for PayPal.
- Trailing-year EPS growth is 5.01% for PayPal versus -85.05% for Block.
- Analysts' estimate for next-year EPS growth is 30.23% for Block versus 6.08% for PayPal.
Profitability, cash flow & financial health
PayPal leads Qanvo's profitability and quality category (100 vs 0, a relative rank within this pair, based on net margin and return on equity). Its operating margin is 18.34% against 8.57% for Block, and its net margin is 13.78% against 1.80%. Return on equity is 23.83% for PayPal and 2.03% for Block. Block's gross margin is 47.50%, up 6.63% over a year, while its operating margin changed by -1.05%; PayPal's operating margin changed by 0.10%. PayPal's gross margin is not given in the facts, so the two cannot be compared on that line. The companies are in different sectors (Financials and Technology), so margins and leverage compare less directly. On cash, PayPal's trailing free cash flow is $6.30B on revenue of $34.30B. Block's is 3.45B on $25.65B, a 13.47% free cash flow margin, with free cash flow growth of 88.54% year over year. Block also leads financial resilience (100 vs 0): debt/equity is 0.33× against 0.69×, net debt is -709.1M (net cash) against 3.19B for PayPal, and interest coverage is 10.43× against 16.77×, which favors PayPal on that one measure. Block's Piotroski F-score is 7 against 6.
- PayPal's net margin of 13.78% is well above Block's 1.80%.
- PayPal's return on equity of 23.83% compares with 2.03% for Block.
- Block's debt/equity of 0.33× is below PayPal's 0.69×, and Block holds net cash of 709.1M while PayPal has net debt of 3.19B.
- PayPal's interest coverage of 16.77× is above Block's 10.43×.
Shareholder returns & capital allocation
PayPal returns capital through both dividends and buybacks; Block returns none through dividends. PayPal's dividend yield is 0.96% (0.56 per share over the trailing year, paid quarterly at 0.14), with a payout ratio of 10.69%. Dividend growth years are 0, so the dividend is new rather than a long-raised one, and annual dividends paid were 130.0M in fiscal 2025 after none in earlier years. Block's dividend yield is 0.00% with no dividends paid, consistent with reinvesting, which is not a weakness in itself. On share count, PayPal's shares changed by -10.62% over the past year, supported by stock repurchases of 6.05B in fiscal 2025 and 6.05B in 2024. Diluted shares fell from 1.04B to 968.0M over the last two reported fiscal years. Block's share count fell by 1.11%, with repurchases of 2.33B in fiscal 2025, up from 1.17B in 2024, while diluted shares moved from 636.4M to 622.8M. PayPal is shrinking its share base far faster, helped by free cash flow of $6.30B against Block's 3.45B. Block's insider activity is heavy selling (58 sells in 90 days, net -36.8M) versus PayPal's 8 sells (net -514.7K), mostly tax withholding.
- PayPal yields 0.96% with a 10.69% payout ratio, while Block pays no dividend (0.00%).
- PayPal's share count fell 10.62% over one year against 1.11% for Block.
- PayPal repurchased 6.05B of stock in fiscal 2025, versus 2.33B for Block.
- Block's buybacks roughly doubled from 1.17B in 2024 to 2.33B in 2025.
Earnings intelligence
Over the last four reported quarters PYPL beat EPS estimates each time except one: Oct 27, 2026 at 10.69% (EPS 1.45 vs 1.31 consensus), Jul 28, 2026 at 7.81%, May 5, 2026 at 4.69%, and a miss of -4.65% on Feb 3, 2026. Revenue surprises were mixed: -1.50%, 2.46%, 3.77% and -1.28%. The stock reacted 2.84%, 4.07%, -8.18% and -21.59% respectively. XYZ's last four were Nov 3, 2026 (EPS 1.13 vs 1.03, 9.71% surprise, revenue 2.03%), Aug 5 (17.11%, 2.22%), May 7 (25.93%, 0.42%) and Feb 26 (-0.31%, -0.42%). Price moves were 13.69%, -6.64%, 5.68% and 22.64%. XYZ's surprises were larger in the last three quarters and its revenue beats were consistent, but its reactions were bigger in both directions. Estimate revisions over 30 days favour PYPL on EPS (3.77% vs 2.19% for XYZ), while revenue revisions are -0.63% for PYPL and 0.52% for XYZ. Both show a three-quarter EPS beat streak. Qanvo's earnings momentum scorecard has PYPL as the leader (100 vs 33). PYPL's next report is Feb 2, 2027, before market open, not confirmed. XYZ has no upcoming date on file, so it may report sooner than screens assume. No guidance figures appear in the facts. The latest reports helped both: PYPL's beat came with a small revenue miss, while XYZ's beat came with a revenue beat and a large positive reaction.
- PYPL's latest EPS surprise was 10.69% versus 9.71% for XYZ, though XYZ's revenue surprise (2.03%) was positive and PYPL's was -1.50%.
- The latest reactions were 2.84% for PYPL and 13.69% for XYZ, and XYZ's eight-quarter average earnings move is 12.79% versus 7.66% for PYPL.
- The 30-day EPS revision is 3.77% for PYPL versus 2.19% for XYZ, both analyst estimates.
- PYPL's next report is estimated for Feb 2, 2027 (unconfirmed), 77 days away; XYZ has no date on file.
Technicals, relative performance & risk
Over 1 year XYZ's price return was 34.7% (total 34.7%) against -6.1% for PYPL (total -5.1%). Over 3 years XYZ was 33.9% versus 2.0% (total 3.1% for PYPL). PYPL led over 1 month (2.8% vs 2.4%) and 6 months (30.9% vs 12.3%); XYZ led over 3 months (-1.1% vs -3.9%) and 5 years (-65.8% vs -71.8%). Relative strength ratings are 87 for PYPL and 91 for XYZ, and Qanvo's momentum scorecard favours XYZ (60 vs 40). Both trade above their 200-day averages: PYPL by 15.76% and XYZ by 9.75%. Versus the 50-day, PYPL is 4.17% above and XYZ 1.41% above; versus the 20-day, PYPL is 0.05% above and XYZ 1.47% below. RSI(14) is 51.9 for PYPL and 47.65 for XYZ. PYPL is 9.10% below its 52-week high of 63.93, XYZ 11.24% below its 89.40. Risk is mixed in the scorecard. XYZ's beta is 1.77 versus 0.9, and 30-day historical volatility is 56.47% versus 24.43%. PYPL's one-year maximum drawdown was -37.87% against -31.31% for XYZ. XYZ fell 4.35% on the latest day. Conflict: PYPL screens cheaper on valuation, but XYZ has stronger one-year price momentum.
- XYZ's 1-year price return of 34.7% compares with -6.1% for PYPL, while PYPL's 6-month return of 30.9% is above XYZ's 12.3%.
- PYPL sits 15.76% above its 200-day average versus 9.75% for XYZ.
- XYZ's beta is 1.77 versus 0.9, and its 30-day volatility is 56.47% versus 24.43%.
- Maximum 1-year drawdown was -37.87% for PYPL and -31.31% for XYZ.
Analyst & ownership sentiment
Analysts' opinions point in different directions. The consensus label for PayPal is Hold, with a rating score of 2.71 from 26 analysts, while Block's is Buy at 2.29 from 25 analysts. The mean analyst target for PayPal is 56.45, which is -2.86% below the latest price of 58.11. Block's mean target is 95.11, which is 19.86% above its price of 79.35. These are opinions, not forecasts. In the last 30 days PayPal had 0 upgrades and 2 downgrades, while Block had 2 upgrades and 0 downgrades. Over the same period, analysts' EPS estimates were revised up by 3.77% for PayPal and 2.19% for Block. Institutional ownership is similar at 72.30% for PayPal and 74.75% for Block. Three-month changes are +0.73% and +2.89%. These come from filings that lag by weeks. Insiders sold in both: PayPal had 8 sales and no buys in 90 days, with a net value of -514.7K. Block had 58 sales and no buys, with a net value of -36.8M. Short interest is modest for both: 3.36% of float for PayPal (2.25 days to cover) and 2.37% for Block (3.35 days to cover).
- Analysts' mean target implies -2.86% for PayPal versus 19.86% for Block, though targets are opinions.
- Block had 2 upgrades and 0 downgrades in 30 days; PayPal had 0 upgrades and 2 downgrades.
- Insider net selling over 90 days was -36.8M at Block versus -514.7K at PayPal.
- Short interest is 3.36% of float at PayPal versus 2.37% at Block.
Risks & catalysts
Valuation and estimate risk differ. PayPal's forward P/E of 9.86× is above its industry median of 7.13×, yet below Block's 15.10×. Block's trailing P/E of 103.67× is far above its forward multiple, so its price leans heavily on analysts' estimates: EPS next fiscal year is expected to grow 30.23%, versus 6.08% for PayPal. If those estimates slip, Block has more to lose. Block's reported EPS growth was -85.05% year on year, and its net margin is 1.80% against PayPal's 13.78%. Volatility and balance sheet also differ. Block's beta is 1.77 against 0.9 for PayPal, and its 30-day historical volatility is 56.47% against 24.43%. Its average earnings-day move over 8 quarters is 12.79%, versus 7.66% for PayPal, including PayPal's 21.59% drop in February 2026. PayPal carries net debt of 3.19B and debt-to-equity of 0.69×, while Block has net cash (net debt of -709.1M) and 0.33×. Block also draws 91.70% of revenue from the United States. Catalysts: PayPal's next earnings are listed for Feb 2, 2027 (not confirmed) and its next ex-dividend date is Dec 4, 2026. No upcoming earnings date is on file for Block.
- Block's 30-day historical volatility of 56.47% is more than double PayPal's 24.43%.
- Block's forward P/E of 15.10× is above PayPal's 9.86×, and it leans on 30.23% expected EPS growth.
- PayPal's debt-to-equity of 0.69× compares with Block's 0.33× and net cash.
- PayPal's next earnings date is Feb 2, 2027, unconfirmed; Block has no date on file.
Analysis written November 18, 2026. AI-generated, for information only; not investment advice.