Palo Alto Networks, Inc. (PANW) vs CrowdStrike Holdings, Inc. (CRWD) vs Fortinet, Inc. (FTNT)
FTNT leads on value and profitability; CRWD on growth and momentum; PANW sits between them
All three are US cybersecurity companies in Software - Infrastructure, but the scorecard splits the leadership: FTNT is cheapest and most profitable (valuation score 100, quality score 100), while CRWD leads growth (75) and technical momentum (100) and has the strongest balance sheet by the scorecard. PANW is second or middle on most categories and has the most free cash flow at $4.11B. Last-year revenue growth is close for PANW (24.49%) and CRWD (24.30%), with FTNT at 20.23%, so the gap is mostly in profit and price. Risk is mixed with no clear leader, and all three have fallen sharply over the past month. Sentiment, valuation and recent price action pull in different directions.
Business overview
All three are US-listed Technology companies in Software - Infrastructure, and all describe cybersecurity or network security offerings, so the sector is shared. By market cap, PANW is largest at $244.44B, CRWD is close behind at $229.65B, and FTNT is well below at $90.73B, roughly a third of PANW's size. PANW and CRWD are tiered Mega; FTNT is Large. The profiles show different emphases. PANW provides network security solutions to enterprises, service providers and government entities. CRWD describes cloud-native cybersecurity covering endpoints, cloud workloads, identities and data, with revenue mainly from subscriptions. FTNT describes unified, automated cybersecurity built around a platform that combines hardware and software licenses. Revenue mix differs. CRWD is 94.86% subscription and circulation, PANW is 54.35% subscription, and FTNT's security subscription is 38.73% with product at 32.63%. Geography: the Americas or United States are 66.89% for PANW and 66.85% for CRWD, while FTNT is more international, with Europe, Middle East and Africa at 41.68% and the Americas at 39.71%.
- PANW's $244.44B market cap is about 2.7 times FTNT's $90.73B, with CRWD at $229.65B.
- CRWD's subscription share of 94.86% compares with 54.35% for PANW and 38.73% for FTNT's security subscription line.
- The US or Americas share is 66.89% for PANW and 66.85% for CRWD versus 39.71% for FTNT.
Valuation
Qanvo's scorecard names FTNT the cheapest on average (score 100), with PANW at 33 and CRWD at 0, the lowest of the group. Trailing P/E is 39.75 for FTNT, 796.23 for PANW and 3,928.31 for CRWD. Forward P/E, an estimate-based measure, is 32.14 for FTNT and 74.64 for PANW; none is shown for CRWD because its analyst estimates were left out for a currency mismatch. Price/sales is 11.51 for FTNT, 21.29 for PANW and 42.56 for CRWD. EV/EBITDA is 29.22 for FTNT, 158.36 for PANW and 516.08 for CRWD. PEG is 3.51 for FTNT and 4.64 for PANW. Free-cash-flow yield is 3.78% for FTNT, 1.68% for PANW and 0.68% for CRWD. Against their own 5-year ranges, FTNT's trailing P/E of 39.75 sits just above its low of 31.38 and below its median of 47.69. PANW's 796.23 is near its high of 902.98 versus a median of 116.58. CRWD's 3,928.31 is far above its 12-month range, which tops out at 873.57. Versus the sector median trailing P/E of 29.74, PANW and CRWD are at the 99th and 100th percentiles, and FTNT at the 63rd. FTNT's lower multiples coincide with the highest margins but the slowest expected EPS growth, and a 24.81% fall after its latest report. The richer multiples for PANW and CRWD reflect depressed trailing earnings and faster revenue growth, so the premium rests on future profit expansion.
- Trailing P/E is 39.75 for FTNT against 796.23 for PANW and 3,928.31 for CRWD.
- Free-cash-flow yield is 3.78% for FTNT, 1.68% for PANW and 0.68% for CRWD.
- EV/EBITDA is 29.22 for FTNT versus 158.36 for PANW and 516.08 for CRWD.
- FTNT's trailing P/E of 39.75 is below its 5-year median of 47.69, while PANW's 796.23 is well above its median of 116.58.
Growth
Qanvo's growth scorecard puts CRWD first (75), then PANW (62) and FTNT (25). Reported revenue growth over the last year is 24.49% for PANW, 24.30% for CRWD and 20.23% for FTNT, so the first two are nearly level. Last-quarter growth is 34.45% for PANW, 25.83% for CRWD and 20.49% for FTNT. Over three years, CRWD's 29.01% compound rate is well above PANW's 18.54% and FTNT's 15.46%. EPS tells another story. FTNT's EPS grew 26.75% year over year and 38.71% in the last quarter, with a 3-year compound rate of 31.86%. PANW's EPS fell 72.50% in the year and 197.22% in the quarter, with a 3-year rate of -11.74%. CRWD's EPS growth figures are not provided. The history is consistent. CRWD's annual revenue rose from $874.4M in fiscal 2021 to $4.81B in fiscal 2026, with 34 straight quarters of revenue growth and 5 accelerating quarters. PANW's revenue went from $4.26B to $11.48B, with a quarterly figure of $3.41B in its latest quarter, but net income was negative in its last two quarters. FTNT grew from $2.59B in fiscal 2020 to $6.80B in fiscal 2025, though its revenue accelerating streak is 0. As analyst estimates, expected EPS growth next fiscal year is 16.07% for PANW and 9.15% for FTNT; none is available for CRWD. Consensus EPS for the current fiscal year is 4.18 for PANW and 3.56 for FTNT.
- Last-year revenue growth is 24.49% for PANW, 24.30% for CRWD and 20.23% for FTNT.
- CRWD's 3-year revenue compound rate of 29.01% exceeds PANW's 18.54% and FTNT's 15.46%.
- FTNT's EPS grew 26.75% over the year while PANW's fell 72.50%.
- Analysts estimate next-year EPS growth of 16.07% for PANW versus 9.15% for FTNT.
Profitability, cash flow & financial health
FTNT leads the Qanvo profitability and quality scorecard (100, versus 50 for PANW and 8 for CRWD). Its gross margin is 79.75% against 75.25% for CRWD and 70.36% for PANW. The gap widens lower down: operating margin is 32.98% at FTNT, 6.05% at PANW and -2.21% at CRWD, while net margin is 28.96%, 2.67% and 1.08%. FTNT's return on equity is 153.08%, but its equity base is only $2.25B, so that figure is inflated. ROIC is 2.04% at PANW and -10.40% at CRWD; it is not given for FTNT. On cash, FTNT's trailing free cash flow is $3.43B (43.54% margin), PANW's is $4.11B (35.83%) and CRWD's is $1.57B (29.15%). PANW's cash flow is far above its operating income of $695.0M, so cash and accounting profit diverge there. Over the past year, PANW's operating margin fell 7.42%, and its gross margin fell 3.06%. CRWD's operating margin improved 6.51% and its gross margin rose 1.24%, though it is still negative. FTNT's operating margin rose 2.00% while its gross margin slipped 1.52%. All three hold more cash than debt. Net debt to EBITDA is -9.60× at CRWD, -1.45× at FTNT and -0.37× at PANW. PANW's current ratio is 0.87×, below CRWD's 1.57× and FTNT's 1.40×. FTNT's interest coverage is 175.62×, while CRWD's is -4.48×; PANW's is not given. Debt to equity is 0.09× at PANW, 0.16× at CRWD and 0.22× at FTNT.
- FTNT's operating margin of 32.98% compares with 6.05% at PANW and -2.21% at CRWD.
- PANW generates the most free cash flow at $4.11B, but FTNT converts more of revenue at a 43.54% margin versus 35.83%.
- CRWD has the strongest balance sheet by the scorecard, with net debt to EBITDA of -9.60× and a current ratio of 1.57×.
- Margin direction differs: CRWD's operating margin improved 6.51% over a year while PANW's fell 7.42%.
Shareholder returns & capital allocation
None of the three pays a dividend: each has a dividend yield of 0.00%, so payout ratio and dividend growth do not apply. For companies reinvesting in growth, this is not a weakness; the question is how each uses its cash and what happens to share count. FTNT is the only one shrinking its share count, with shares outstanding down 3.58% over one year. Its latest annual report shows $2.29B of stock repurchased in fiscal 2025, against $600.0K in fiscal 2024 and $1.50B in fiscal 2023, so buybacks are sizeable but uneven. PANW's share count rose 7.76% over the year even though it repurchased $1.00B of stock in fiscal 2026. Its diluted share count was 764.0M against 709.3M the year before. CRWD's share count grew 3.84%, and it reports no stock repurchases in any of the last six fiscal years. On capacity, FTNT's free cash flow of $3.43B and cash of $4.80B support buybacks. PANW's free cash flow of $4.11B is the largest, but dilution has outweighed repurchases. CRWD holds $5.01B of cash against $820.2M of debt and is directing its cash flow of $1.57B toward growth rather than returns. The facts here do not show how much of the dilution comes from stock compensation versus acquisitions, and news mentions a possible $500M PANW purchase that is not confirmed.
- FTNT cut its share count by 3.58% in a year, while PANW's rose 7.76% and CRWD's rose 3.84%.
- PANW repurchased $1.00B of stock in fiscal 2026, yet still saw dilution; CRWD repurchased none.
- FTNT repurchased $2.29B of stock in fiscal 2025, its largest buyback in the last three reported fiscal years.
- All three show a 0.00% dividend yield, so none offers income.
Earnings intelligence
Over the last four reported quarters, all three beat EPS consensus every time, but the stock reactions diverged. PANW beat by 9.69% (Feb 17), 7.19% (Jun 2) and 4.29% (Sep 1), with price moves of -8.75%, -6.67% and -14.04%; the Nov 18, 2026 report is not confirmed. CRWD beat by 2.80% (Mar 3), 3.70% (Jun 3) and 6.31% (Aug 26), with moves of 5.92%, -6.49% and 22.97%; its Dec 1, 2026 date is also not confirmed. FTNT beat by 9.02%, 32.47%, 20.64% and 5.81%, with moves of 2.02%, 20.07%, 2.85% and -24.81%; its Feb 4, 2027 date is not confirmed. Revenue surprises were small for PANW (1.74% latest) and CRWD (2.14%), and 0.71% for FTNT after 8.44% and 6.72% in the two prior quarters. FTNT has the longest EPS beat streak at 35, versus 7 for PANW and 5 for CRWD. Over 30 days, analysts' EPS estimates rose 3.27% for FTNT and were roughly flat for PANW (-0.02%); CRWD's estimates are excluded from the facts. Qanvo's scorecard rates FTNT as the earnings momentum leader. The latest report strengthened CRWD's relative case on price reaction, while FTNT's beat came with a sharp sell-off and several price target cuts.
- FTNT has beaten EPS 35 quarters in a row, versus 7 for PANW and 5 for CRWD.
- The latest reactions were -14.04% for PANW, 22.97% for CRWD and -24.81% for FTNT despite beats of 4.29%, 6.31% and 5.81%.
- Analysts' 30-day EPS estimate revisions were 3.27% for FTNT and -0.02% for PANW; CRWD's are not available.
- None of the next earnings dates is confirmed: Nov 18, 2026 (PANW), Dec 1, 2026 (CRWD), Feb 4, 2027 (FTNT).
Technicals, relative performance & risk
CRWD leads price returns over 1 month (-14.2%), 3 months (0.3%), 6 months (66.5%), 1 year (62.0%) and 3 years (349.4%). PANW is second on those periods (-19.2%, -15.2%, 52.7%, 50.7%, 155.3%) but leads over 5 years at 292.3%. FTNT trails on each period except 1 year, where it is close to PANW at 50.2%. Total returns match price returns, as none pays a dividend. Relative strength ratings are 96 for CRWD, 94 for PANW and 85 for FTNT. All three trade below their 20- and 50-day averages. FTNT is furthest below (-20.10% and -25.67%) and is the only one below its 200-day average (-4.96%), while PANW is 18.65% above and CRWD 31.75% above. RSI is 27.96 for FTNT, 38.7 for PANW and 41.27 for CRWD. From 52-week highs, FTNT is down 37.32%, PANW 24.51% and CRWD 21.34%. The 30-day historical volatility is 80.12% for FTNT, 60.38% for PANW and 60.32% for CRWD; 1-year beta is 1.63 for CRWD, 1.37 for PANW and 1.01 for FTNT. Max 1-year drawdowns are similar: -35.09%, -37.18% and -38.98%. Signals conflict with fundamentals: FTNT has the weakest momentum yet leads on valuation and profitability in the scorecard, while CRWD has the strongest momentum with the most expensive multiples.
- CRWD leads 6-month price returns at 66.5%, ahead of PANW at 52.7% and FTNT at 7.0%.
- FTNT is 37.32% below its 52-week high, versus 24.51% for PANW and 21.34% for CRWD.
- FTNT's 30-day historical volatility is 80.12%, against 60.38% for PANW and 60.32% for CRWD.
- CRWD's 1-year beta is 1.63, above PANW at 1.37 and FTNT at 1.01.
Analyst & ownership sentiment
Analyst opinion is most favourable for PANW and CRWD, and least for FTNT. PANW's rating label is Strong Buy with a rating score of 2.09 from 30 analysts, and CRWD's is Strong Buy with a score of 2 from 67 analysts. FTNT's is Buy with a score of 2.29 from 26 analysts. The latest consensus breakdown shows FTNT as Hold, with 29 Buy, 35 Hold and 6 Sell ratings, against 64 Buy, 23 Hold and 2 Sell for PANW and 52 Buy, 13 Hold and 2 Sell for CRWD. These are analysts' opinions, not outcomes. Mean price targets imply upside of 27.23% for FTNT, 25.45% for PANW and 9.54% for CRWD, which is the narrowest. FTNT saw one downgrade in the past 30 days and a run of target cuts after its Oct 28, 2026 report. Bernstein set CRWD's target at 177 on Nov 9, 2026, below the current price. Institutional ownership is highest at PANW (92.60%), then CRWD (76.81%) and FTNT (68.87%). Filings lag by weeks. Insider activity is net selling everywhere: -40.7M at PANW, -458.2M at CRWD and -30.7M at FTNT, with no insider buys in 90 days. Short float is 2.84% for PANW, 2.38% for CRWD and 1.64% for FTNT.
- CRWD has the most analyst coverage at 67 analysts, but the smallest mean target upside at 9.54%, versus 27.23% for FTNT and 25.45% for PANW.
- FTNT is the only one with a Hold consensus label, with 35 Hold and 6 Sell ratings.
- CRWD's insider net value over 90 days is -458.2M, well above PANW's -40.7M and FTNT's -30.7M in selling.
- FTNT has the lowest short float at 1.64%, versus 2.84% for PANW.
Risks & catalysts
Valuation is the main shared risk, since expectations are embedded in prices. PANW's forward P/E is 74.64×, against 32.14× for FTNT; CRWD has no forward P/E in the facts and a trailing P/E of 3,928.31×. All three trade well above the industry median forward P/E of 18.94×. Both PANW and CRWD have thin or negative operating margins (6.05% and -2.21%), while FTNT's is 32.98%. PANW's operating margin fell 7.42% over the year and its earnings per share growth was -72.50%. Analyst estimates for CRWD were excluded because of a currency mismatch, so there is a gap there. Volatility is high for all. 30-day implied volatility is 73.59% for CRWD, 70.01% for PANW and 45.90% for FTNT. One-year maximum drawdowns are -37.18%, -35.09% and -38.98% respectively. FTNT fell 24.81% after its last report, a reminder of event risk, and news items mention a law-firm fraud investigation notice, with no further detail given. Catalysts: PANW reports on Nov 18, 2026 (not confirmed), with an implied move of 12.62%. CRWD's report is expected Dec 1, 2026 (not confirmed), with an implied move of 13.53%. FTNT's next report is expected Feb 4, 2027. None pays a dividend.
- PANW's forward P/E of 74.64× is more than double FTNT's 32.14×.
- PANW reports in 8 days (Nov 18, 2026) and CRWD in 21 days (Dec 1, 2026), while FTNT is 86 days away.
- CRWD's 30-day implied volatility of 73.59% is the highest, above PANW's 70.01% and FTNT's 45.90%.
- FTNT's 24.81% post-earnings drop compares with PANW's 14.04% drop last time and CRWD's 22.97% gain.
Analysis written November 11, 2026. AI-generated, for information only; not investment advice.