Realty Income Corporation (O) vs VICI Properties Inc. (VICI)
Realty Income: faster reported growth, calmer shares; VICI: far lower multiples, higher yield, weaker trend
The scorecard splits across the two REITs: VICI leads valuation (100 versus 0), profitability and quality (100 versus 0) and financial resilience (80 versus 20), while Realty Income leads growth (75 versus 25), earnings momentum (100 versus 0), technical momentum (80 versus 20) and lower risk (75 versus 25). VICI trades at a forward P/E of 8.43× against 34.89× for Realty Income and yields 7.38% against 5.59%. Realty Income has grown revenue faster (8.64% versus 4.70% over the last year) and has stronger price performance over 1 year (1.8% versus -18.7%). Analysts' estimates point the other way for next-year EPS growth (19.22% for VICI versus 9.18% for Realty Income), but VICI's estimates are being cut. The two have different tenant bases, so retail and gaming-focused leases are not directly comparable.
Business overview
Both are US-listed Real Estate REITs on the NYSE and S&P 500 members, but they are not the same business model. Realty Income (REIT - Retail) describes itself as "The Monthly Dividend Company," with over 6,500 commercial properties leased to various businesses under long-term contracts. VICI Properties (REIT - Diversified) focuses on experiential properties: 29 gaming facilities, over 48 million square feet, about 19,200 hotel rooms and more than 200 dining, bar and nightlife venues, including Caesars Palace, leased to gaming and hospitality operators. Realty Income is larger, with a market cap of $54.80B against $26.97B for VICI, and an enterprise value of $85.83B versus $44.53B. Both are classed as large. Realty Income's segment data show a United States geography at 100.00% of revenue; VICI's only disclosed segment is a single real property segment from fiscal 2021. Employee counts are 544 for Realty Income and 28 for VICI. Because tenants differ (broad commercial lessees versus gaming and hospitality operators), tenant concentration and cyclicality are not directly comparable from these facts.
- Realty Income's market cap of $54.80B is roughly double VICI's $26.97B.
- Realty Income is classed as REIT - Retail with over 6,500 properties, while VICI is REIT - Diversified with 29 gaming facilities.
- Realty Income reports 544 employees against 28 at VICI.
Valuation
VICI is the cheaper company on nearly every multiple, and the scorecard names it the valuation leader (100 versus 0 for Realty Income, a relative rank within this pair). Trailing P/E is 11.50× for VICI against 38.90× for Realty Income; forward P/E, based on analyst estimates, is 8.43× versus 34.89×. PEG is 0.44× versus 3.80×, price/sales 6.49× versus 9.01×, and EV/EBITDA 13.78× versus 17.40×. Free-cash-flow yield is 10.02% for VICI against 3.88% for Realty Income. Against their own five-year trailing P/E ranges, Realty Income's 38.90× sits below its median of 52.77× and above its low of 35.10×. VICI's 11.50× is below its median of 12.72× and above its low of 8.90×. Versus sector peers, Realty Income's trailing P/E is at percentile 77 (sector median 27.60×), while VICI's is at percentile 8 (sector median 27.57×). The gap may partly reflect different circumstances. VICI's latest EPS missed consensus by 56.94%, its analyst EPS estimates were revised down 9.98% over 30 days, and its shares fell 19.27% over a year. Realty Income's higher multiple comes with lower returns on capital (ROIC 1.94% versus 5.46%) and a high payout ratio of 223.93%. Neither multiple is a verdict on value.
- VICI's trailing P/E of 11.50× compares with 38.90× for Realty Income.
- Free-cash-flow yield is 10.02% for VICI versus 3.88% for Realty Income.
- Realty Income's PEG of 3.80× is far above VICI's 0.44×.
- Versus sector peers, VICI's trailing P/E is at percentile 8 and Realty Income's at percentile 77.
Growth
On the scorecard Realty Income leads growth (75 versus 25), though the picture is mixed. Reported revenue growth over the last year is 8.64% for Realty Income and 4.70% for VICI; last quarter it was 10.27% versus 5.76%; the 3-year compound rate is 19.80% versus 15.49%. On EPS, Realty Income grew 34.26% over the last year and 22.86% in the latest quarter, while VICI fell 16.79% and 56.34%. Over three years, however, Realty Income's EPS compound rate is -6.25% against 27.14% for VICI. The annual history shows Realty Income revenue rising from $1.65B in fiscal 2020 to $5.75B in 2025, with diluted EPS moving unevenly (1.14, 0.87, 1.42, 1.26, 0.98, 1.17) as the share count grew. VICI's revenue rose from $1.23B to $4.01B, with EPS up from 1.75 to 2.61 and a 20-quarter revenue-up streak. VICI's quarterly EPS slid from 0.82 in Q1 FY2026 to 0.31 in Q3. Analyst estimates, which are opinions, point the other way for next year: expected EPS growth is 19.22% for VICI versus 9.18% for Realty Income. Consensus EPS for the current fiscal year is 2.49 for VICI and 1.54 for Realty Income.
- Realty Income's last-year revenue growth is 8.64% versus 4.70% for VICI.
- Realty Income's last-year EPS growth is 34.26% while VICI's is -16.79%.
- VICI's 3-year EPS compound growth is 27.14% against -6.25% for Realty Income.
- Estimated next-year EPS growth is 19.22% for VICI versus 9.18% for Realty Income.
Profitability, cash flow & financial health
VICI leads the profitability and quality scorecard (100 against 0 for Realty Income, a relative rank within this pair). Its gross margin is 98.88% against 69.14%, operating margin 77.40% against 28.38%, and net margin 56.46% against 23.15%. Return on invested capital is 5.46% against 1.94%, and return on equity 8.28% against 3.59%. Free cash flow is $2.70B for VICI (65.05% margin) against $2.13B for Realty Income (34.94% margin). REIT margins and returns should be read against REIT peers, not industrial companies. On balance sheets VICI also leads the resilience scorecard (80 against 20). Net debt/EBITDA is 5.43× against 6.29×, debt/equity 0.61× against 0.79×, and interest coverage 3.81× against 1.41×. Both have thin liquidity, with current ratios of 0.45× for VICI and 0.51× for Realty Income. Over time, both saw operating margin fall: -15.19% for VICI and -16.03% for Realty Income over one year. Realty Income's free cash flow growth was -42.96% year on year, while VICI's was 9.85%. Realty Income's revenue is growing faster, but that growth has not yet lifted margins or returns.
- VICI's operating margin of 77.40% is well above Realty Income's 28.38%.
- VICI's interest coverage is 3.81× against 1.41× for Realty Income.
- Free cash flow margin is 65.05% for VICI against 34.94% for Realty Income.
- Net debt/EBITDA is 5.43× for VICI and 6.29× for Realty Income, so both are leveraged.
Shareholder returns & capital allocation
VICI pays the higher dividend yield at 7.38% (quarterly, $1.81 per share over the trailing year) against 5.59% for Realty Income (monthly, $3.25 per share). The payout ratio is the bigger difference: 83.03% for VICI against 223.93% for Realty Income. Payout ratios based on net income are distorted for REITs by depreciation, so they are an imperfect guide for both, but the gap is wide. Three-year dividend growth is similar at 5.57% for VICI and 5.51% for Realty Income. VICI shows 7 years of growth in the data against 1 for Realty Income, although the company profile says Realty Income has raised its payout 109 times since going public in 1994. Share count rose in both: 3.67% for Realty Income and 3.02% for VICI over one year, so both are diluting modestly. VICI's latest news mentions a $2B buyback plan and a $500 million term loan, which the facts do not detail. Realty Income's dividends paid are $2.92B in fiscal 2025 against free cash flow of $3.99B, while VICI paid $1.85B against $2.51B.
- VICI yields 7.38% against 5.59% for Realty Income.
- The payout ratio is 83.03% for VICI against 223.93% for Realty Income.
- Three-year dividend growth is nearly level at 5.57% for VICI and 5.51% for Realty Income.
- Share count grew 3.67% at Realty Income and 3.02% at VICI over one year.
Earnings intelligence
Over the last four reported quarters, Realty Income (O) and VICI had different surprise patterns. O's EPS versus consensus was 5.70% above on Nov 2, 2026 (actual 0.43 versus 0.4068), then -6.97%, -18.03% and -16.56% in the three prior reports. VICI's was -56.94% on Oct 28, 2026 (0.31 versus 0.72), then -32.68%, 15.98% and -18.10%. VICI therefore missed in three of four and O in three of four, but O's latest was a beat and VICI's was its largest miss. Revenue surprises were positive for both: O ranged from 1.54% to 13.34%, VICI from 0.36% to 1.89%. The stock reactions were small. O moved 1.00% after the latest report, against an implied 3.19%. VICI rose 3.46% against an implied 3.98%. In the earlier three, O moved -0.86%, -2.80% and -1.03%, and VICI -2.92%, 1.92% and -1.65%. No upcoming earnings date is on file for either company, so the next date is neither confirmed nor reliably estimated. Analyst EPS estimates over 30 days moved 1.23% higher for O and -9.98% lower for VICI. No guidance figures appear in the facts. Qanvo's earnings momentum category leads with O (100 versus 0), so the latest report strengthened O's relative case and weakened VICI's.
- O's latest EPS surprise was 5.70% against VICI's -56.94%.
- Analyst EPS estimates moved 1.23% for O and -9.98% for VICI over 30 days.
- Latest-report price moves were 1.00% for O and 3.46% for VICI, both inside implied moves of 3.19% and 3.98%.
- Revenue surprises were positive for both, 13.34% for O and 0.50% for VICI in the latest quarter.
Technicals, relative performance & risk
Relative performance is mixed. By price return, VICI leads over 1 month (6.1% versus 4.6%) and 3 months (-5.6% versus -7.0%), while O leads over 6 months (-5.9% versus -14.0%), 1 year (1.8% versus -18.7%) and 3 years (9.1% versus -14.3%). VICI leads again over 5 years (-16.0% versus -19.4%). With dividends reinvested, O's 1-year total return is 6.9% against VICI's -13.0%, but VICI's 5-year total return is 10.9% against O's 4.2%. Both trade below the 200-day average: O by 5.64%, VICI by 8.40%. Both are above the 50-day average (2.24% and 2.45%) and close to the 20-day. The 14-day RSI is similar, 51.56 for O and 51.26 for VICI. O is 14.57% below its 52-week high; VICI is 19.61% below. The relative strength rating is 46 for O and 34 for VICI. On risk, O's 30-day historical volatility is 18.66% against VICI's 26.01%, one-year beta is -0.06 versus 0.01, and the 1-year drawdown is -21.03% versus -25.79%. Qanvo's momentum and risk categories both lead with O. The technicals partly conflict with fundamentals: VICI leads valuation, yet has the weaker price trend.
- O's 1-year price return is 1.8% versus VICI's -18.7%.
- VICI sits 8.40% below its 200-day average, against 5.64% for O.
- O's 30-day volatility is 18.66% versus 26.01% for VICI.
- Maximum 1-year drawdown was -21.03% for O and -25.79% for VICI.
Analyst & ownership sentiment
Analysts' opinions lean more favorably toward VICI Properties. Its consensus label is Buy (rating score 2.25, five analysts in the estimate set), against Hold for Realty Income (rating score 2.71, eight analysts). The rating tallies show 21 Buy and 7 Hold for VICI with no Sell, versus 13 Buy, 19 Hold and 3 Sell for Realty Income. Mean price targets are analysts' opinions, not forecasts: $28.38 for VICI implies 15.79% upside, while Realty Income's $74.47 implies 28.31%. Realty Income's mean is lifted by one Mizuho target of 187, well above the other targets of 59 to 65. Recent revisions have been negative for both. VICI's 30-day EPS estimate revision is -9.98%, while Realty Income's is 1.23%. Scotiabank downgraded Realty Income to Sector Perform on Sep 24, 2026, and Barclays reiterated Reduce on Oct 20, 2026. Institutional ownership is 98.14% for VICI and 81.28% for Realty Income, with 3-month changes of 1.62% and 2.72%. These filings lag by weeks. Realty Income had one insider sale (-209.0K) in 90 days; VICI had no insider buys or sells. Short interest is 4.48% of float for Realty Income, up 10.11%, versus 2.73% for VICI, down 5.50%.
- VICI's consensus is Buy with 21 Buy ratings and no Sell, while Realty Income is Hold with 19 Hold and 3 Sell.
- Mean target upside is 28.31% for Realty Income versus 15.79% for VICI, though Realty Income's average is skewed by a 187 outlier.
- The 30-day EPS revision is -9.98% for VICI against 1.23% for Realty Income.
- Short interest is 4.48% of float for Realty Income versus 2.73% for VICI.
Risks & catalysts
Leverage is a shared risk. Realty Income's net debt/EBITDA is 6.29x and interest coverage is 1.41x, versus 5.43x and 3.81x for VICI. Both current ratios are below 1 (0.51x and 0.45x). Qanvo's scorecard gives VICI the stronger financial resilience. Realty Income's payout ratio of 223.93% compares with 83.03% for VICI, though REIT payout ratios based on net income are not directly comparable to cash-flow measures. Valuation and estimates cut differently. Realty Income's forward P/E of 34.89x is above VICI's 8.43x, so it leaves more room for disappointment. VICI's low multiple reflects market skepticism, and its forward figures depend on analyst estimates that are being cut (-9.98% revision), after its last EPS missed consensus by -56.94%. Realty Income's latest EPS beat by 5.70%, but its history of earlier misses is long. Volatility is higher at VICI: 30-day historical volatility of 26.01% against 18.21% at 10 days for Realty Income, and a 1-year drawdown of -25.79% versus -21.03%. VICI's implied volatility is 27.14% with backwardation. Its facts describe leases to gaming operators, including Caesars Entertainment, so tenant and sector concentration matters; the data does not quantify it. Catalysts: Realty Income's ex-dividend date is Nov 30, 2026 (monthly payout of 0.274). No upcoming earnings date is on file for either company.
- Net debt/EBITDA is 6.29x for Realty Income versus 5.43x for VICI, and interest coverage is 1.41x versus 3.81x.
- Realty Income's payout ratio is 223.93% versus 83.03% for VICI.
- VICI's 1-year drawdown is -25.79% versus -21.03% for Realty Income.
- Realty Income's next ex-dividend date is Nov 30, 2026; no confirmed earnings date is on file for either.
Analysis written November 18, 2026. AI-generated, for information only; not investment advice.