Compare stocks

Micron Technology, Inc. (MU) vs Western Digital Corporation (WDC) vs Seagate Technology Holdings plc (STX)

MU: fastest growth and cheapest multiples; STX calmest; WDC leads revisions; all in steep drawdowns

MU leads Qanvo's scorecard on valuation (83), growth (75), profitability and quality (67), financial resilience (80) and technical momentum (100), with a forward P/E of 3.89× against 9.25× for WDC and 10.04× for STX. WDC leads earnings momentum (100) on a 30-day EPS revision of 20.22%, and STX leads the lower risk profile category (75) with a beta of 1.65. All three are far below 52-week highs, with 30-day volatility near 90% or higher. Analysts expect next-year EPS growth of 20.22% for MU against 63.45% for WDC and 64.70% for STX, so the growth lead is on reported history, not estimates. MU is a memory chipmaker while WDC and STX make storage devices, so multiples are not like-for-like.

Business overview

Micron Technology (MU) is the largest of the three, with a market cap of $805.03B (Mega tier), against $115.00B for Seagate (STX) and $103.70B for Western Digital (WDC), both Large tier. All three trade on NASDAQ and are in the Technology sector, but the industries differ: MU is classed as Semiconductors, while WDC and STX are both Computer Hardware. Per its profile, MU provides memory and storage solutions through four business units. Its fiscal 2026 revenue was led by the United States at 68.57%, then Taiwan at 12.73%. WDC designs and markets data storage devices (HDDs and SSDs) plus flash-based embedded storage. Its fiscal 2026 revenue was 88.94% Cloud, with the Americas at 43.72%. STX is described as a provider of mass-capacity storage, including nearline HDDs, SSDs and enterprise nearline systems. Its revenue was 50.40% United States and 40.02% Singapore. The business models differ: MU is a memory chipmaker, while WDC and STX are mainly storage-device makers, so memory pricing and disk-drive demand are not identical drivers. STX is domiciled in Singapore per the data, which is relevant for geographic comparisons.

  • MU's market cap of $805.03B is roughly seven times that of STX at $115.00B.
  • WDC derives 88.94% of fiscal 2026 revenue from Cloud, a concentration not shown in MU's or STX's disclosed segments.
  • MU is classed as Semiconductors while WDC and STX are Computer Hardware, so peer multiples are not like-for-like.

Valuation

On trailing P/E, MU is lowest at 9.47×, then WDC at 10.35× and STX at 26.16×. On forward P/E (an estimate-based measure), MU is 3.89×, WDC 9.25× and STX 10.04×. EV/EBITDA runs 7.04× for MU, 16.48× for WDC and 20.79× for STX. Price/sales is 6.04× for MU, 7.16× for WDC and 8.33× for STX. PEG is 0.19× for MU, 0.15× for WDC and 0.16× for STX, so WDC is lowest there. Free-cash-flow yield is 7.32% for MU, 4.14% for WDC and 3.61% for STX. Qanvo's valuation scorecard names MU the cheapest (score 83, vs 58 for WDC and 8 for STX). Against its own 5-year range, MU's trailing P/E of 9.47× is below its median of 20.25×, WDC's 10.35× is below 14.31×, and STX's 26.16× is above its 22.83× median. Versus the sector peer median of 28.26×, MU sits at the 4th percentile, WDC the 6th and STX the 43rd. Cheaper multiples may partly reflect that earnings are at cyclical highs and the stocks are very volatile, with 30-day volatility above 90% for all three. MU's low multiple coincides with the strongest growth and margins, so it is not obviously a weaker-quality discount.

  • MU's forward P/E of 3.89× is well below WDC's 9.25× and STX's 10.04×.
  • STX's trailing P/E of 26.16× is above its 5-year median of 22.83×, while MU and WDC are below theirs.
  • MU's free-cash-flow yield of 7.32% is roughly double WDC's 4.14% and STX's 3.61%.
  • WDC has the lowest PEG at 0.15×, just under STX at 0.16× and MU at 0.19×.

Growth

Reported growth is strongest at MU: revenue up 256.33% year over year and 379.27% in the latest quarter, with a 3-year compound rate of 104.65%. WDC shows 43.02%, 55.46% and 27.35%; STX shows 44.37%, 61.01% and 18.20%. Reported EPS growth over the year was 877.87% for MU, 283.43% for WDC and 144.67% for STX. Qanvo's growth scorecard puts MU first (75), with WDC and STX tied at 38. The history shows all three recovering from weak years. In fiscal 2023, MU had revenue of $15.54B and a net loss; fiscal 2026 revenue was $133.19B. WDC went from $6.32B in fiscal 2024 to $12.92B in fiscal 2026, and STX from $6.55B to $12.20B. Each has six consecutive quarters of rising revenue. MU's quarterly revenue rose from $13.64B to $54.23B across fiscal 2026, and it has five accelerating quarters, against four for STX and one for WDC. Analyst estimates differ in shape. Expected next-year EPS growth is 20.22% for MU, 63.45% for WDC and 64.70% for STX. These are estimates, and they imply a sharp slowdown for MU from a very high base while WDC and STX are expected to grow faster.

  • MU's reported revenue growth of 256.33% is about six times WDC's 43.02% and STX's 44.37%.
  • STX's latest-quarter revenue growth of 61.01% edges WDC's 55.46%.
  • Analysts' next-year EPS growth estimates are 64.70% for STX, 63.45% for WDC and 20.22% for MU.
  • MU has five accelerating revenue quarters versus four for STX and one for WDC.

Profitability, cash flow & financial health

Micron leads Qanvo's profitability and quality scorecard with a score of 67, against 50 for Seagate and 33 for Western Digital. Its gross margin is 80.72% versus 52.60% for Western Digital and 50.35% for Seagate, and its operating margin is 74.59% versus 39.50% for Seagate and 39.41% for Western Digital. Free cash flow margin follows the same order: Micron 44.27%, Seagate 30.13%, Western Digital 29.62%. Net margin and returns are more mixed. Western Digital's net margin is 69.20% against 63.80% for Micron and 31.86% for Seagate, but its trailing net income of $10.02B is well above its operating income of $5.71B, so it is not purely operating profit. Seagate's ROIC of 94.73% is above Micron's 78.38% and Western Digital's 51.10%. Its ROE of 259.35% reflects a small equity base of $3.45B, so it should be read with caution. On the balance sheet, Micron holds net cash (net debt/EBITDA -0.35×, debt/equity 0.04×). Western Digital also has net cash (-0.08×, 0.08×). Seagate carries net debt (0.20×, 0.68×) and the lowest interest coverage at 22.25×, versus 53.34× for Western Digital and 937.17× for Micron. Margins have widened at all three: operating margin change over one year is 48.18% for Micron, 16.55% for Seagate and 11.83% for Western Digital.

  • Micron's gross margin of 80.72% is well above Western Digital's 52.60% and Seagate's 50.35%.
  • Seagate's ROIC of 94.73% is the highest, ahead of Micron's 78.38% and Western Digital's 51.10%.
  • Micron and Western Digital hold net cash, while Seagate has net debt/EBITDA of 0.20× and debt/equity of 0.68×.
  • Interest coverage is 937.17× for Micron, 53.34× for Western Digital and 22.25× for Seagate.

Shareholder returns & capital allocation

None of the three is primarily an income stock, and payouts are small relative to earnings. Seagate yields the most at 0.59% ($2.96 per share over the last twelve months) with a 15.53% payout ratio, and it has raised its dividend for 2 years. Western Digital yields 0.19% with a 2.08% payout ratio, and Micron 0.08% with a 0.76% payout ratio. Dividend growth over three years is 1.18% for Seagate and 1.11% for Micron, while Western Digital's is -40.09%. Its dividend has risen in recent quarters, from $0.125 to $0.175 for the payment due in December. Share counts rose at all three over the past year: 2.65% for Seagate, 2.13% for Western Digital and 1.96% for Micron, so dilution is slightly lower at Micron. Buybacks differ in scale. In the latest fiscal year Western Digital repurchased $2.59B of stock, Micron $1.78B and Seagate $176.0M. Seagate paid $634.0M in dividends, versus $174.0M for Western Digital and $610.0M for Micron. Micron's free cash flow of $58.96B is large relative to its payouts, but its capital spending is also heavy at $30.71B over the last twelve months. Seagate's debt paydown is mentioned in recent news, but no detail is given in the data.

  • Seagate's dividend yield of 0.59% leads Western Digital's 0.19% and Micron's 0.08%.
  • Share count grew 2.65% at Seagate, 2.13% at Western Digital and 1.96% at Micron over one year.
  • Western Digital repurchased $2.59B in the latest fiscal year, above Micron's $1.78B and Seagate's $176.0M.
  • Payout ratios are 15.53% for Seagate, 2.08% for Western Digital and 0.76% for Micron.

Earnings intelligence

Over the last four reported quarters all three beat EPS consensus, but with different stock reactions. MU's surprises were 5.19% (Sep 30, 2026), 19.69%, 32.75% and 20.71%, with price moves of 3.03%, 15.38%, -3.77% and 6.90%. WDC's were 12.90% (Oct 22, 2026), 7.55%, 13.81% and 10.36%, with moves of -9.20%, -1.53%, 4.55% and -10.54%. STX's were 3.23% (Oct 27, 2026), 11.96%, 16.81% and 11.87%, with moves of 8.35%, -6.43%, 7.96% and 23.62%. Latest revenue surprises were 5.64% for MU, 5.72% for WDC and 2.04% for STX. Beat streaks are 14 quarters for MU, 18 for WDC and 12 for STX. Analysts' 30-day EPS revisions are 20.22% for WDC, 9.91% for STX and 0.25% for MU, which is why Qanvo's earnings momentum leader is WDC (score 100, versus 33 for MU and 17 for STX). Next reports, none confirmed: MU Dec 23, 2026, STX Jan 27, 2027, WDC Feb 4, 2027. No guidance figures are in the facts. The latest report looks strongest for WDC on revisions, though the stock fell 9.20% after it. STX had the smallest EPS surprise but the best reaction. MU's smaller latest beat and flat revisions leave it behind on this measure.

  • WDC's 30-day EPS revision of 20.22% is well above STX at 9.91% and MU at 0.25%.
  • MU's latest EPS surprise of 5.19% trails WDC at 12.90% but is above STX at 3.23%.
  • WDC has the longest beat streak at 18 quarters versus 14 for MU and 12 for STX.
  • After the latest report WDC fell 9.20% while STX rose 8.35% and MU rose 3.03%.

Technicals, relative performance & risk

All three are in sharp pullbacks, but MU has held up best over most horizons. Price returns: 1 month WDC -19.6%, MU -21.3%, STX -23.7%; 3 months MU -29.6%, WDC -47.1%, STX -49.3%; 6 months MU 4.5%, STX -31.9%, WDC -38.2%; 1 year MU 194.4%, STX 93.0%, WDC 74.4%. Total returns are nearly identical because dividends are small, with STX showing the largest gap (3-year 594.8% total versus 554.6% price). RSI (14-day) is 37.54 for MU, 36.77 for WDC and 35.33 for STX. Versus the 200-day average, MU is -7.30%, STX -28.13% and WDC -32.89%; all sit below their 20-day and 50-day averages. WDC had a death cross on Nov 2, 2026, while MU's 50-day average is still 21.28% above its 200-day. Relative strength rating is 96 for MU, 70 for STX and 42 for WDC. Risk is high for all: 30-day historical volatility is 91.58% for MU, 92.56% for WDC and 90.35% for STX. Beta is 3.45, 3.2 and 1.65, and 1-year drawdown is -45.91%, -64.65% and -57.86%. Versus the 52-week high, they are -43.23%, -64.58% and -55.95%. Strong fundamental growth contrasts with weak recent price trends, especially for WDC and STX. This is descriptive, not a forecast.

  • MU's 3-month price return of -29.6% is less negative than WDC at -47.1% and STX at -49.3%.
  • STX has the lowest beta at 1.65 versus 3.45 for MU and 3.2 for WDC.
  • WDC has the deepest 1-year drawdown at -64.65%, against -57.86% for STX and -45.91% for MU.
  • MU's relative strength rating of 96 compares with 70 for STX and 42 for WDC.

Analyst & ownership sentiment

Analysts' opinions are favorable across all three, though they differ in breadth. MU carries a "Strong Buy" rating label on a rating score of 2.09 from 30 analysts, with a mean target of 1,597.27 (an opinion, not a forecast) that sits 124.20% above the 712.42 price. WDC and STX are both labeled "Buy" with a rating score of 2.25. WDC's mean target is 586.44, 106.98% above its price, and STX's is 1,009.80, 100.20% above. STX has the most Hold ratings (20) and Sell ratings (4), and one downgrade in the last 30 days, while MU and WDC show none. Estimate revisions over 30 days were largest for WDC (EPS 20.22%), then STX (9.91%), then MU (0.25%). Institutions hold 94.31% of WDC, 85.74% of STX and 78.52% of MU. Filings lag by weeks. Three-month changes were -1.14% for WDC, 1.08% for STX and 2.42% for MU. Insiders show no open-market buys at any of the three over 90 days. Insider net value was -349.3M for STX (327 sells), -70.3M for MU (58 sells) and -12.7M for WDC (29 sells); several MU entries are tax withholding. Short interest is highest at WDC (5.29% of float, 2.14 days to cover), then STX (3.70%) and MU (2.07%).

  • MU's mean analyst target implies 124.20% upside versus 106.98% for WDC and 100.20% for STX, all analysts' opinions.
  • WDC's 30-day EPS estimate revision of 20.22% is well above STX at 9.91% and MU at 0.25%.
  • STX insider net value of -349.3M compares with -70.3M at MU and -12.7M at WDC, and none of the three shows insider buying.
  • WDC's short float of 5.29% is more than double MU's 2.07%.

Risks & catalysts

Volatility is the shared risk. Thirty-day historical volatility is 92.56% for WDC, 91.58% for MU and 90.35% for STX. One-year maximum drawdowns were -64.65% (WDC), -57.86% (STX) and -45.91% (MU). Each trades roughly 44% to 65% below its 52-week high after 3-month price declines of -29.6% (MU), -47.1% (WDC) and -49.3% (STX). Qanvo's risk scorecard puts STX as calmest and WDC as the most volatile of the group. Valuation and estimates matter as well. MU's forward P/E of 3.89 and WDC's 9.25 rest on consensus EPS, while STX at 10.04 has the highest trailing P/E (26.16) and a price/book of 33.31 on thin equity. STX is the only one with net debt (1.09B) and a debt/equity ratio of 0.68, against MU's net cash. WDC's 2026 net income was boosted far above operating income (9.42B vs 4.45B), so its P/E needs caution. MU's news flow includes a NAND price forecast cut and glut warning. WDC has a shareholder-investigation notice, and its death cross was on Nov 2, 2026. Catalysts: MU reports Dec 23, 2026 (unconfirmed), STX Jan 27, 2027, WDC Feb 4, 2027. WDC goes ex-dividend Dec 4, 2026 and STX Dec 23, 2026.

  • Maximum 1-year drawdown was -64.65% at WDC versus -45.91% at MU.
  • STX carries net debt of 1.09B and debt/equity of 0.68, while MU holds net cash of 38.26B.
  • MU's next earnings date, Dec 23, 2026, comes 36 days out, versus 71 days for STX and 79 for WDC, and none is confirmed.
  • Average earnings-day moves over 8 quarters were 10.66% for STX, 7.42% for MU and 7.04% for WDC.

Analysis written November 18, 2026. AI-generated, for information only; not investment advice.