McDonald's Corporation (MCD) vs Starbucks Corporation (SBUX)
MCD: cheaper, higher margins, weak 1-year chart; SBUX: stronger price trend, richer multiples, thin margins
Qanvo's scorecard gives McDonald's the lead on valuation (80 vs 20), growth (75 vs 25), profitability and quality (80 vs 20), financial resilience (75 vs 25) and lower risk (75 vs 25). Starbucks leads only on technical momentum (80 vs 20), and earnings momentum is mixed with no clear leader. McDonald's trades at a forward P/E of 20.28× against 33.47× for Starbucks, with an operating margin of 46.44% against 9.65%. Starbucks has the stronger price record over the past year (28.4% vs -9.5%) and a higher ROIC (26.57% vs 19.25%), but analysts expect next-year EPS growth of -2.07% for Starbucks versus 5.82% for McDonald's. Both carry meaningful leverage and negative equity, so the trade-off is price trend and recovery against valuation and earnings visibility.
Business overview
Both companies sit in Consumer Discretionary, in the Restaurants industry, and both are large caps. McDonald's, at $195.36B market cap, is about 1.6 times the size of Starbucks at $123.03B. Per its profile, McDonald's operates and franchises fast-food restaurants in the United States and internationally, with a menu of burgers, chicken, fries, breakfast items, desserts and coffee. Starbucks roasts, markets and sells specialty coffee through North America, International and Channel Development divisions, with coffee, tea, food and packaged products, and it licenses its brand to independently operated stores and grocery retailers. The footprints differ. McDonald's fiscal 2025 revenue was split 50.71% International Operated Markets, 40.26% United States and 9.03% International Developmental Licensed Markets and Corporate. Starbucks fiscal 2026 revenue was 94.18% United States and 5.82% China, with beverages at 59.12%, other products 21.34% and food 19.54%. Starbucks reports higher revenue ($37.90B trailing versus $27.78B) but far lower margins, so the models differ in economics even within one industry. Fiscal years end in different months.
- McDonald's market cap of $195.36B compares with $123.03B for Starbucks.
- Starbucks trailing revenue of $37.90B exceeds McDonald's $27.78B.
- Starbucks draws 94.18% of fiscal 2026 revenue from the United States, while McDonald's US share is 40.26%.
- Employees: Starbucks 306,000 versus McDonald's 150,000.
Valuation
McDonald's is cheaper on every multiple shown, and Qanvo's scorecard names it the valuation leader (score 80 against 20 for Starbucks, relative ranks within this pair). Trailing P/E is 21.72× versus 48.69×; forward P/E, based on analyst estimates, is 20.28× versus 33.47×. Price/sales is 7.03× for McDonald's and 3.25× for Starbucks, the one measure where Starbucks is lower, reflecting its far thinner margins. EV/EBITDA is 16.87× versus 23.79×. PEG is 3.48× for McDonald's; it is not shown for Starbucks. Free-cash-flow yield is 3.83% versus 3.03%. Against its own 5-year range, McDonald's trailing P/E of 21.72 sits below its median of 26.02 and near the low end of 18.76 to 35.42. Starbucks at 48.69 is well above its median of 31.67 within a 20.12 to 81.01 range. Versus sector peers, McDonald's trailing P/E is at the 60th percentile (sector median 20.66×) and Starbucks at the 94th. Starbucks' premium coincides with depressed recent earnings and weaker expected EPS growth, while McDonald's has higher margins and lower volatility, so its lower multiple is not explained by weaker quality.
- Trailing P/E is 21.72× for McDonald's versus 48.69× for Starbucks.
- Forward P/E (estimate-based) is 20.28× versus 33.47×, against an industry median of 20.75×.
- Free-cash-flow yield is 3.83% for McDonald's versus 3.03% for Starbucks.
- Starbucks' trailing P/E sits at the 94th sector percentile versus the 60th for McDonald's.
Growth
Qanvo's growth scorecard favors McDonald's (75 against 25), though the picture is mixed. Reported revenue growth over the last year is 5.78% for McDonald's versus 1.93% for Starbucks; the latest quarter is 1.12% versus -4.47%; the 3-year compound rate is 5.06% versus 1.76%. On EPS, Starbucks shows a rebound: 34.76% year over year and 391.67% in the latest quarter, but from a depressed base, and its 3-year compound EPS growth is -14.85%. McDonald's EPS grew 7.85% year over year, 10.38% in the latest quarter, and 12.78% on a 3-year compound basis. History: McDonald's annual revenue rose from $23.18B in fiscal 2022 to $26.89B in fiscal 2025, with EPS from 8.33 to 11.95. Starbucks revenue rose from $32.25B to $37.91B by fiscal 2026, but EPS fell from 3.58 in fiscal 2023 to 1.63 in fiscal 2025 before recovering to 2.21. Starbucks' recent quarterly revenue has slipped from $9.91B to $9.14B. Analyst estimates: expected EPS growth next fiscal year is 5.82% for McDonald's and -2.07% for Starbucks, whose FY2 consensus EPS of 3.15 is below FY1's 3.22. McDonald's estimates are 12.94 and 13.69.
- Latest-year revenue growth is 5.78% for McDonald's versus 1.93% for Starbucks.
- Latest-quarter revenue growth is 1.12% versus -4.47%, favoring McDonald's.
- Three-year compound EPS growth is 12.78% for McDonald's versus -14.85% for Starbucks.
- Analysts estimate next-year EPS growth of 5.82% for McDonald's versus -2.07% for Starbucks.
Profitability, cash flow & financial health
MCD leads the scorecard on profitability and quality (80 vs 20 for SBUX, relative ranks within this pair). Its margins are far higher: gross margin 57.20% vs 42.67%, operating margin 46.44% vs 9.65%, net margin 32.38% vs 6.67%. Free cash flow also favors MCD in scale and margin: $7.49B at a 26.97% FCF margin, against 3.72B at 9.83% for SBUX. The gross margin comparison is imperfect because the two companies' cost structures differ (franchising vs company-operated stores). SBUX does lead on return on invested capital at 26.57% vs 19.25%, and its Piotroski F-score is 9 vs 7. Its free cash flow grew 52.53% year over year vs 1.63% for MCD, and EPS growth was 34.76% vs 7.85%, but from a depressed base: SBUX's annual EPS was 1.63 in fiscal 2025 and 2.21 in fiscal 2026, below 3.58 in fiscal 2023. MCD's operating margin edged up 0.36% over the year. On leverage, MCD is more indebted relative to earnings in net debt/EBITDA terms at 3.62× vs 3.12× for SBUX. Both have negative equity (-343.0M vs -7.67B), so debt/equity is not meaningful. MCD has the stronger liquidity: current ratio 1.23× vs 0.76×, and interest coverage 7.93× vs 6.57×.
- MCD's operating margin of 46.44% is well above SBUX's 9.65%.
- SBUX's ROIC of 26.57% is above MCD's 19.25%, the one return measure where it leads.
- MCD's net debt/EBITDA is 3.62× vs 3.12× for SBUX, but its current ratio of 1.23× is above SBUX's 0.76×.
- SBUX's EPS growth of 34.76% is recovering from a lower base, while MCD's is 7.85%.
Shareholder returns & capital allocation
Both companies pay quarterly dividends, with MCD offering a higher yield: 2.70% vs 2.32%. The payout ratio shows a bigger gap: 58.86% for MCD vs 112.67% for SBUX, meaning SBUX's dividend exceeded its trailing earnings. SBUX's dividends paid of 2.82B in fiscal 2026 compare with free cash flow of 3.72B, so cash flow still covers it. MCD paid 5.12B against 7.19B of free cash flow in 2025. Dividend track record also favors MCD: 29 years of growth vs 15 for SBUX, and 3-year dividend growth of 8.20% vs 7.00%. MCD's next quarterly payment is 1.93 per share (ex-dividend Dec 1, 2026), up from 1.86. On share count, MCD is shrinking its base, with shares down 1.06% over a year and repurchases of 2.06B in 2025 (below 2.82B in 2024 and 3.05B in 2023). SBUX's shares rose 0.32%, and its annual data shows no repurchases (0.00) in fiscal 2025 and 2026, so it is directing cash to dividends and its balance sheet rather than buybacks.
- MCD's dividend yield is 2.70% vs 2.32% for SBUX.
- MCD's payout ratio is 58.86%, about half of SBUX's 112.67%.
- MCD has raised its dividend for 29 years vs 15 for SBUX.
- MCD's share count fell 1.06% while SBUX's rose 0.32%.
Earnings intelligence
Over the last four reported quarters MCD beat EPS consensus every time: 3.57 vs 3.38 (5.62% surprise) on Nov 4, 2026, 3.38 vs 3.32 (1.81%), 2.83 vs 2.74 (3.28%) and 3.12 vs 3.05 (2.30%). Its revenue surprises were mixed: -1.75%, -0.42%, 0.71% and 2.50%. Stock moves were 5.70%, 3.31%, -2.94% and 1.87%. SBUX's EPS surprises were larger but less consistent: 0.80 vs 0.719 (11.27%), 0.85 vs 0.66 (28.79%), 0.5 vs 0.4253 (17.56%), then a miss of -4.44% in January. Its reactions were 0.46%, 2.67%, 7.77% and -1.92%. The scorecard shows earnings momentum as mixed, with no clear leader. Next reports: MCD on Feb 10, 2027 and SBUX on Jan 27, 2027, both not confirmed. On revisions, MCD's 30-day EPS estimate revision is 0.43% and its revenue revision -1.02%; none is given for SBUX. SBUX's consensus is $3.22 for this fiscal year and $3.15 for the next, a decline. MCD's is $12.94 then $13.69. No guidance is in the facts. The latest report slightly reinforced MCD's steadiness, and SBUX's larger beat came with a revenue miss of -0.90%.
- MCD's latest EPS surprise was 5.62% against 11.27% for SBUX, though MCD's beat streak is 4 quarters versus 3.
- Both missed revenue consensus last quarter: MCD by -1.75% and SBUX by -0.90%.
- The latest earnings-day move was 5.70% for MCD versus 0.46% for SBUX.
- Analysts' consensus EPS rises from 12.94 to 13.69 for MCD and slips from 3.22 to 3.15 for SBUX.
Technicals, relative performance & risk
Price returns are split by period. MCD leads over 1 month (13.7% vs 9.8%), 3 months (3.9% vs -0.4%) and 5 years (9.2% vs -4.5%). SBUX leads over 6 months (0.8% vs -2.4%), 1 year (28.4% vs -9.5%) and 3 years (3.1% vs -1.2%). With dividends reinvested, 1-year totals are 30.8% for SBUX and -7.2% for MCD. The relative strength rating is 85 for SBUX and 50 for MCD, and the scorecard gives SBUX technical momentum. SBUX is 6.82% above its 200-day average and 7.98% above its 50-day, with RSI of 58.11. MCD is -1.85% below its 200-day but 9.88% above its 50-day, with RSI of 64.9. Its 50-day sits -10.68% below its 200-day. SBUX is -3.60% from its 52-week high; MCD is -19.29% from its high. On risk, MCD's beta is 0.05 against 0.59, 30-day historical volatility is 27.13% vs 31.31%, and its 1-year maximum drawdown is -32.31% vs -16.40% for SBUX. SBUX's stronger chart sits beside weaker growth estimates, while MCD's rebound sits beside a weak 1-year record.
- SBUX's 1-year price return of 28.4% compares with -9.5% for MCD, while MCD's 1-month return of 13.7% exceeds 9.8%.
- SBUX trades 6.82% above its 200-day average, while MCD is -1.85% below.
- MCD's 1-year beta is 0.05 against 0.59 for SBUX, and 30-day volatility is 27.13% vs 31.31%.
- MCD's 1-year maximum drawdown of -32.31% is deeper than SBUX's -16.40%, despite its lower beta.
Analyst & ownership sentiment
Analysts' opinions are close on the label but differ in detail. MCD carries a consensus rating of Buy with a rating score of 2.14 across 20 analysts, and SBUX is labelled Strong Buy with a score of 2 across 21 analysts. The mean target is 283.92 for MCD, which is 2.94% above the price of 275.82, versus 118.17 for SBUX, which is 9.94% above 107.49. These are opinions, not forecasts. The SBUX target rests on 6 targets over three months against 25 for MCD. In the last 30 days SBUX had 2 upgrades and 1 downgrade, while MCD had none of either. Institutions hold 86.36% of SBUX, up 3.80% over three months, and 75.11% of MCD, up 0.81%. Those filings lag by weeks. Neither company shows insider buying in the last 90 days. MCD had 2 insider sells, net -417.2K, and SBUX had 4 sells, net -694.9K. Short interest is 3.84% of float for SBUX (5.41 days to cover) versus 1.65% for MCD (2.33 days), and MCD's short interest fell 13.50% in the latest period.
- SBUX's mean target sits 9.94% above its price, against 2.94% for MCD, which is an analyst estimate.
- SBUX short interest of 3.84% of float is more than double MCD's 1.65%.
- Institutional ownership is higher at SBUX (86.36%) than at MCD (75.11%), and it rose faster over three months (3.80% versus 0.81%).
- Insider selling was larger at SBUX (net -694.9K) than at MCD (net -417.2K), with no buys at either.
Risks & catalysts
Valuation is the clearest risk difference. SBUX trades at a forward P/E of 33.47 and a trailing P/E of 48.69, against 20.28 and 21.72 for MCD, so SBUX has less room for earnings to disappoint. Estimates also matter: analysts expect next-year EPS growth of -2.07% for SBUX and 5.82% for MCD, and SBUX's recent quarterly revenue growth was -4.47%. SBUX margins are thinner, with an operating margin of 9.65% versus 46.44% at MCD, and its payout ratio is 112.67% against 58.86%. Leverage is meaningful at both. Net debt to EBITDA is 3.62× for MCD and 3.12× for SBUX, and both report negative equity. SBUX has a current ratio of 0.76× versus 1.23× for MCD. On volatility, MCD's one-year maximum drawdown was -32.31% against -16.40% for SBUX, and MCD is 19.29% below its 52-week high. Catalysts: MCD's next ex-dividend date is Dec 1, 2026 (dividend 1.93). Next earnings are Feb 10, 2027 for MCD and Jan 27, 2027 for SBUX, and neither date is confirmed. SBUX is 94.18% US revenue, so it is more concentrated than MCD, where the US is 40.26%.
- SBUX's forward P/E of 33.47 compares with 20.28 for MCD, so valuation risk is higher at SBUX.
- MCD's one-year maximum drawdown of -32.31% is roughly double SBUX's -16.40%.
- SBUX's current ratio is 0.76× versus 1.23× for MCD, a thinner short-term liquidity cushion.
- Next earnings are Jan 27, 2027 for SBUX and Feb 10, 2027 for MCD, both unconfirmed, and MCD's ex-dividend date is Dec 1, 2026.
Analysis written November 18, 2026. AI-generated, for information only; not investment advice.