Caterpillar Inc. (CAT) vs Deere & Company (DE)
CAT: cheaper, faster-growing, stronger balance sheet but broken momentum; DE: strong price trend, richer valuation
Caterpillar leads Qanvo's scorecard on valuation (100 vs 0), growth (75 vs 25), profitability and quality (67 vs 33) and financial resilience (100 vs 0). Deere leads on earnings momentum (100 vs 0), technical momentum (100 vs 0) and lower risk profile (75 vs 25). Caterpillar has a forward P/E of 18.06× against 28.41× for Deere, and last-year revenue growth of 20.26% against 9.87%, yet it trades 46.83% below its 52-week high while Deere is 9.98% below. Analysts' next-year EPS growth estimates are close (18.23% for Caterpillar, 20.06% for Deere), so the main trade-off is reported fundamentals and valuation versus recent price strength and lower volatility. Both are cyclical equipment makers with financing arms, so debt ratios are not purely industrial.
Business overview
Both companies sit in Industrials and are classed under Agricultural - Machinery, but their profiles differ. Caterpillar is described as a manufacturer of heavy construction and mining equipment, diesel and natural gas power units, and industrial gas turbines. Deere is described as a global manufacturer and distributor of equipment, organized into Production and Precision Agriculture, Small Agriculture and Turf, Construction and Forestry, and Financial Services. Caterpillar is the larger company, with a market cap of $262.05B (Mega tier) against $175.16B for Deere (Large tier). Caterpillar has 118,000 employees and Deere 73,100. Caterpillar's fiscal 2025 revenue was led by Power & Energy at 39.69% and Construction Industries at 36.26%. Deere's was led by Production & Precision Ag at 37.12%. Both are U.S.-centred: North America is 54.16% of Caterpillar's revenue and the United States is 52.48% of Deere's. Financial Products is 6.17% of Caterpillar's revenue and 13.78% of Deere's.
- Caterpillar's market cap of $262.05B is above Deere's $175.16B.
- Power & Energy is 39.69% of Caterpillar's fiscal 2025 revenue, while Deere's largest segment, Production & Precision Ag, is 37.12%.
- Financial Products is 13.78% of Deere's revenue against 6.17% for Caterpillar, so Deere has the larger financing arm.
Valuation
Deere is the more expensive stock on most multiples, and Qanvo's valuation scorecard names Caterpillar the leader (100 against 0). Trailing P/E is 22.15× for Caterpillar and 35.95× for Deere. Forward P/E, based on analyst estimates, is 18.06× against 28.41×. EV/EBITDA is 16.34× against 19.58×, and PEG is 0.99× against 1.42×. Price/sales is closer at 3.37× against 3.67×. Free-cash-flow yield is 3.67% for Caterpillar and 2.21% for Deere. Against its own 5-year range, Caterpillar's trailing P/E of 22.15× sits between a low of 13.13× and a high of 52.98×, above its median of 17.95×. Deere's 35.95× is near the top of its range (10.63× to 37.53×) and well above its 18.86× median. Against Industrials peers, Caterpillar's trailing P/E is at the 31st percentile (sector median 27.18×) and Deere's at the 79th. The premium for Deere is not matched by faster growth or higher quality in the data. Its trailing EPS growth is negative and its returns on capital are lower, though analysts' expected EPS growth next year is similar. Caterpillar's cheaper multiples come with higher volatility, so the discount may partly reflect risk.
- Forward P/E is 18.06× for Caterpillar against 28.41× for Deere, an analyst-estimate-based gap.
- Caterpillar's trailing P/E of 22.15× is above its 5-year median of 17.95×, and Deere's 35.95× is above its median of 18.86×.
- Free-cash-flow yield is 3.67% for Caterpillar against 2.21% for Deere.
- PEG is 0.99× for Caterpillar against 1.42× for Deere.
Growth
On reported history, Caterpillar is growing faster and more consistently. Revenue growth over the last year is 20.26% against 9.87% for Deere, and last-quarter growth is 17.26% against 7.00%. Over three years, Caterpillar's revenue compound growth is 4.38% while Deere's is -4.50%. EPS growth over the last year is 30.79% for Caterpillar and -5.91% for Deere; last-quarter EPS growth is 45.81% against 7.37%. Three-year EPS compound growth is 14.21% against -7.37%. The annual record shows the difference. Caterpillar's diluted EPS went from 20.12 in fiscal 2023 to 22.05 in 2024 and 18.83 in 2025. Deere's fell from 34.63 to 25.62 to 18.5 over the same years. Quarterly revenue shows Caterpillar at 20.68B in Q3 FY2026, up from 17.64B a year earlier, and Deere at 12.61B, up from 11.78B. Fiscal years end in different months. Analyst estimates point the other way slightly: expected EPS growth next fiscal year is 20.06% for Deere and 18.23% for Caterpillar. Consensus EPS for the following year is 32.20 for Caterpillar and 27.21 for Deere. These are opinions, not results. Qanvo's growth scorecard names Caterpillar the leader (75 against 25).
- Last-year revenue growth is 20.26% for Caterpillar against 9.87% for Deere.
- Three-year EPS compound growth is 14.21% for Caterpillar against -7.37% for Deere.
- Analysts expect next-fiscal-year EPS growth of 20.06% for Deere against 18.23% for Caterpillar, which is an estimate.
- Deere's fiscal 2025 diluted EPS of 18.5 is below its fiscal 2023 figure of 34.63, while Caterpillar's 18.83 is below its 2023 figure of 20.12 by a smaller margin.
Profitability, cash flow & financial health
Qanvo's scorecard gives CAT the lead on profitability and quality (67 vs 33 for DE) and on financial resilience (100 vs 0). Margins are close at the top: DE has a higher gross margin (35.74% vs 34.33%) and operating margin (18.97% vs 18.33%), but CAT converts more to the bottom line, with a net margin of 15.21% vs 10.22%. Returns differ sharply: CAT's ROIC is 19.17% vs 8.73%, and its ROE is 56.14% vs 18.33%, though CAT's ROE is inflated by a small equity base relative to its debt. Cash flow follows the same pattern. CAT's trailing free cash flow is 9.62B (12.36% margin) against 3.87B (8.11% margin) for DE. The trend also differs: CAT's operating margin rose 0.59% over the year, while DE's fell 0.99% and its gross margin fell 1.96%, so DE's revenue growth of 9.87% has not yet improved its economics. On the balance sheet, CAT's net debt/EBITDA is 2.04× vs 4.61× for DE, interest coverage is 16.27× vs 3.12×, and the current ratio is 1.42× vs 0.77×. Debt/equity is similar (2.10× vs 2.29×). Both carry financing arms, so debt ratios include financing-related borrowing.
- CAT's net margin is 15.21% vs 10.22% for DE, while DE leads narrowly on gross margin (35.74% vs 34.33%).
- CAT's ROIC is 19.17% vs 8.73% for DE, and its free cash flow margin is 12.36% vs 8.11%.
- CAT's net debt/EBITDA is 2.04× vs 4.61× for DE, and its interest coverage is 16.27× vs 3.12×.
- CAT's operating margin improved 0.59% over the year, while DE's declined 0.99%.
Shareholder returns & capital allocation
DE offers the lower yield, but it is easier to compare on the numbers: CAT's dividend yield is 1.39% with a payout ratio of 31.03%, against 1.00% and 36.00% for DE. DE's three-year dividend growth is faster (12.84% vs 8.12%), but CAT has raised its dividend for 12 years against 5 for DE. CAT's quarterly payment rose to 1.63 from 1.51 during the past year, while DE's has held at 1.62. On buybacks, CAT's share count fell 2.10% over the year, against 0.26% for DE. In the latest fiscal year, CAT repurchased 5.21B of stock and paid 2.75B in dividends, versus 1.14B and 1.72B for DE. DE's repurchases were 4.01B in the prior year and 7.22B two years earlier, so it has pulled back as earnings declined. Free cash flow gives context: CAT's 9.62B trailing figure is well above DE's 3.87B, which leaves CAT more room to fund both payouts. DE's payout draws on a thinner cash base, and its FCF yield is 2.21% vs 3.67% for CAT.
- CAT's dividend yield is 1.39% vs 1.00% for DE, with a lower payout ratio of 31.03% vs 36.00%.
- DE's three-year dividend growth is 12.84% vs 8.12% for CAT, but CAT's streak is 12 years vs 5.
- CAT's share count fell 2.10% over the year vs 0.26% for DE.
- CAT repurchased 5.21B of stock in fiscal 2025 vs 1.14B for DE.
Earnings intelligence
Over the last four reported quarters, both companies beat EPS estimates each time, but the stock reactions diverged. Caterpillar reported EPS of 7.20 versus consensus of 7.06 on Oct 29, 2026 (a 1.98% surprise) with a revenue surprise of -0.36%, and the stock moved -12.70%. Before that, it beat by 31.35% (Aug 4), 19.14% (Apr 30) and 9.55% (Jan 29). Deere reported EPS of 5.1 versus 4.69 on Aug 20, 2026 (8.74% surprise, revenue surprise 16.58%), and the stock moved 11.51%. Its prior reports surprised by 14.91%, 19.80% and 2.34%, with moves of -5.59%, 11.67% and -6.75%. Estimate revisions over 30 days are slightly negative for Caterpillar (EPS -0.57%, revenue -0.64%) and roughly flat for Deere (EPS -0.05%, revenue 0.03%). Qanvo's earnings momentum scorecard favours Deere (100 versus 0 for Caterpillar), helped by its 20-quarter beat streak versus 5. The latest report weakened Caterpillar's near-term case, while Deere's larger beat helped its own. Caterpillar's next report is Feb 4, 2027 (estimated, not confirmed); Deere's is Nov 25, 2026 (estimated, not confirmed), 8 days away. No guidance appears in the facts.
- Caterpillar's latest EPS surprise was 1.98% with a -12.70% reaction, versus Deere's 8.74% with 11.51%.
- Deere's EPS beat streak is 20 quarters versus Caterpillar's 5.
- Deere reports in 8 days (Nov 25, 2026), while Caterpillar's next report is 79 days away (Feb 4, 2027); neither date is confirmed.
- 30-day EPS revisions: Caterpillar -0.57% versus Deere -0.05%.
Technicals, relative performance & risk
Deere leads the recent windows by price return: 1 month 3.5% versus -21.4% for Caterpillar, 3 months 8.2% versus -35.3%, 6 months 15.0% versus -33.9%, and 1 year 36.4% versus 3.4%. Dividends change little (1-year total return 38.0% versus 4.0%). Over longer spans Caterpillar is ahead: 3 years 127.9% versus 70.7%, and 5 years 181.2% versus 83.6% (total 204.8% versus 96.0%). Caterpillar trades 29.22% below its 200-day average and 21.90% below its 50-day, with a death cross on Oct 21, 2026, an RSI of 31.38, and a price 46.83% below its 52-week high. Deere sits 5.75% above its 200-day and 2.66% below its 50-day, with an RSI of 43.75 and a price 9.98% under its 52-week high. Risk also differs: beta (1-year) is 1.82 for Caterpillar and 0.46 for Deere; 30-day historical volatility is 53.54% versus 30.44%; the 1-year maximum drawdown is -48.01% versus -20.13%. Relative strength ratings are 21 and 90. Technicals conflict with fundamentals for Caterpillar, which leads on valuation, growth and quality in the scorecard despite weak price action. Deere shows the reverse: strong momentum but higher valuation. This is descriptive, not a forecast.
- Over 6 months Deere returned 15.0% versus Caterpillar's -33.9%, but over 5 years Caterpillar returned 181.2% versus 83.6%.
- Caterpillar is 29.22% below its 200-day average, while Deere is 5.75% above.
- Relative strength rating is 90 for Deere versus 21 for Caterpillar.
- 1-year maximum drawdown is -48.01% for Caterpillar versus -20.13% for Deere.
Analyst & ownership sentiment
Analysts' opinions are favorable for both, though the facts show different detail. CAT carries a "Strong Buy" rating label from 17 analysts with a mean target of $878.17 (analysts' estimate), which is 53.85% above the $570.79 price. DE carries the same label from 18 analysts with a mean target of $726.11, 11.84% above its $649.23 price. The consensus breakdown reads 31 Buy, 22 Hold and 4 Sell for CAT versus 20 Buy, 20 Hold and 6 Sell for DE. These are opinions, not outcomes. Revisions diverge slightly: CAT's 30-day EPS revision is -0.57% and DE's is -0.05%. Recent CAT target cuts include Wells Fargo from 1,155 to 840 and Truist from 1,225 to 1,100. DE saw upgrades from Evercore ISI and Nomura, and no upgrades or downgrades were recorded in 30 days for either. Institutional ownership is 72.56% for CAT and 75.86% for DE, per 13F filings as of Jun 30, 2026, which lag by weeks. Insiders were net sellers at both: CAT had 2 buys and 14 sells (-25.4M net) and DE had 0 buys and 21 sells (-23.4M). Short interest is 1.78% of float for CAT and 1.95% for DE, with days to cover of 2.36 versus 5.6.
- CAT's mean analyst target implies 53.85% upside versus 11.84% for DE, but these are opinions and CAT's targets have been cut recently.
- CAT's 30-day EPS revision of -0.57% is weaker than DE's -0.05%.
- Insider net selling over 90 days is similar: -25.4M at CAT versus -23.4M at DE.
- DE's short interest of 1.95% of float and 5.6 days to cover is higher than CAT's 1.78% and 2.36 days.
Risks & catalysts
Valuation is the clearest DE risk: forward P/E of 28.41 against an industry median of 17.78, and a trailing P/E of 35.95 near the top of its five-year range (max 37.53). Its balance sheet is also more stretched, with net debt to EBITDA of 4.61 versus 2.04 for CAT, interest coverage of 3.12 versus 16.27, and a current ratio of 0.77. Its EPS fell 5.91% over the last year and margins narrowed. CAT's risks are price-related and estimate-related. The stock is 46.83% below its 52-week high, fell 12.70% after the Oct 29 earnings report, and sits 29.22% below its 200-day average, with a death cross on Oct 21, 2026. Its one-year beta is 1.82 versus 0.46 for DE, and its one-year max drawdown is -48.01% versus -20.13%. A law firm investigation notice appeared in news on Nov 17; the facts give no further detail. Both depend on analyst estimates for forward growth, and both are cyclical equipment makers. Catalysts: DE reports on Nov 25, 2026 (not confirmed), with an implied move of 9.25%. CAT's next report is Feb 4, 2027 (not confirmed). CAT's last ex-dividend date was Oct 26, 2026 with payment on Nov 19.
- DE's forward P/E of 28.41 is well above CAT's 18.06 and the 17.78 industry median.
- DE's net debt to EBITDA of 4.61 compares with 2.04 for CAT.
- CAT's one-year max drawdown of -48.01% is more than double DE's -20.13%.
- DE's earnings on Nov 25, 2026 come 8 days out, while CAT's are 79 days away on Feb 4, 2027.
Analysis written November 18, 2026. AI-generated, for information only; not investment advice.